andrew_gelman_stats andrew_gelman_stats-2010 andrew_gelman_stats-2010-177 knowledge-graph by maker-knowledge-mining
Source: html
Introduction: Michael Gilligan, Eric Mvukiyehe, and Cyrus Samii write : We [Gilligan, Mvukiyehe, and Samii] use original survey data, collected in Burundi in the summer of 2007, to show that a World Bank ex-combatant reintegration program implemented after Burundi’s civil war caused significant economic reintegration for its beneficiaries but that this economic reintegration did not translate into greater political and social reintegration. Previous studies of reintegration programs have found them to be ineffective, but these studies have suffered from selection bias: only ex-combatants who self selected into those programs were studied. We avoid such bias with a quasi-experimental research design made possible by an exogenous bureaucratic failure in the implementation of program. One of the World Bank’s implementing partners delayed implementation by almost a year due to an unforeseen contract dispute. As a result, roughly a third of ex-combatants had their program benefits withheld for reas
sentIndex sentText sentNum sentScore
1 Previous studies of reintegration programs have found them to be ineffective, but these studies have suffered from selection bias: only ex-combatants who self selected into those programs were studied. [sent-2, score-1.015]
2 We avoid such bias with a quasi-experimental research design made possible by an exogenous bureaucratic failure in the implementation of program. [sent-3, score-0.374]
3 One of the World Bank’s implementing partners delayed implementation by almost a year due to an unforeseen contract dispute. [sent-4, score-0.316]
4 As a result, roughly a third of ex-combatants had their program benefits withheld for reasons unrelated to their reintegration prospects. [sent-5, score-0.837]
5 We conducted our survey during this period, constructing a control group from those unfortunate ex-combatants whose benefits were withheld. [sent-6, score-0.136]
6 We find that the program provided a significant income boost, resulting in a 20 to 35 percentage point reduction in poverty incidence among ex-combatants. [sent-7, score-0.36]
7 We also find moderate improvement in ex-combatants’ livelihood prospects. [sent-8, score-0.098]
8 However, these economic effects do not seem to have caused greater political integration. [sent-9, score-0.499]
9 While we find a modest increase in the propensity to report that civilian life is preferable to combatant life, we find no evidence that the program contributed to more satisfaction with the peace process or a more positive disposition toward current government institutions. [sent-10, score-1.222]
10 Reintegration programs are central in current peace processes and considerable resources are devoted to them. [sent-11, score-0.41]
11 While we find strong evidence for the effectiveness in terms of economic reintegration, our results challenge theories stating that short-run economic conditions are a major determinant of one’s disposition toward society and the state. [sent-13, score-0.915]
12 Social and political integration of ex-combatants likely requires much more than individually-targeted economic assistance. [sent-14, score-0.243]
13 This seems important for policy and I hope will get some attention. [sent-15, score-0.064]
14 Form a statistical perspective, they use a cool identification strategy: As noted in the abstract above, they take advantage of a bureaucratic failure. [sent-16, score-0.136]
wordName wordTfidf (topN-words)
[('reintegration', 0.619), ('economic', 0.178), ('burundi', 0.177), ('gilligan', 0.177), ('mvukiyehe', 0.161), ('disposition', 0.152), ('samii', 0.145), ('programs', 0.14), ('program', 0.139), ('bureaucratic', 0.136), ('peace', 0.122), ('propensity', 0.119), ('bank', 0.109), ('find', 0.098), ('implementation', 0.096), ('terms', 0.095), ('caused', 0.091), ('greater', 0.09), ('current', 0.09), ('benefits', 0.079), ('evidence', 0.077), ('beneficiaries', 0.076), ('delayed', 0.076), ('incidental', 0.076), ('ineffective', 0.076), ('unforeseen', 0.076), ('effects', 0.075), ('bias', 0.072), ('determinant', 0.07), ('exogenous', 0.07), ('preferable', 0.07), ('civilian', 0.068), ('partners', 0.068), ('toward', 0.067), ('political', 0.065), ('life', 0.064), ('policy', 0.064), ('cyrus', 0.063), ('incidence', 0.062), ('significant', 0.061), ('heterogeneity', 0.06), ('suffered', 0.058), ('translate', 0.058), ('boost', 0.058), ('inverse', 0.058), ('devoted', 0.058), ('modest', 0.058), ('self', 0.058), ('civil', 0.058), ('survey', 0.057)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 1.0 177 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-02-Reintegrating rebels into civilian life: Quasi-experimental evidence from Burundi
Introduction: Michael Gilligan, Eric Mvukiyehe, and Cyrus Samii write : We [Gilligan, Mvukiyehe, and Samii] use original survey data, collected in Burundi in the summer of 2007, to show that a World Bank ex-combatant reintegration program implemented after Burundi’s civil war caused significant economic reintegration for its beneficiaries but that this economic reintegration did not translate into greater political and social reintegration. Previous studies of reintegration programs have found them to be ineffective, but these studies have suffered from selection bias: only ex-combatants who self selected into those programs were studied. We avoid such bias with a quasi-experimental research design made possible by an exogenous bureaucratic failure in the implementation of program. One of the World Bank’s implementing partners delayed implementation by almost a year due to an unforeseen contract dispute. As a result, roughly a third of ex-combatants had their program benefits withheld for reas
2 0.10906684 242 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-29-The Subtle Micro-Effects of Peacekeeping
Introduction: Eric Mvukiyehe and Cyrus Samii write : We [Mvukiyehe and Samii] use original survey data and administrative data to test a theory of the micro-level impacts of peacekeeping. The theory proposes that through the creation of local security bubbles and also through direct assistance, peacekeeping deployments contribute to economic and social revitalization that may contribute to more durable peace. This theory guides the design of current United Nations peacekeeping operations, and has been proposed as one of the explanations for peacekeeping’s well-documented association with more durable peace. Our evidence paint a complex picture that deviates substantially from the theory. We do not find evidence for local security bubbles around deployment base areas, and we do not find that deployments were substantial contributors to local social infrastructure. In addition, we find a negative relationship between deployment basing locations and NGO contributions to social infrastructure.
3 0.088796116 98 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-19-Further thoughts on happiness and life satisfaction research
Introduction: As part of my continuing research project with Grazia and Roberto, I’ve been reading papers on happiness and life satisfaction research. I’ll share with you my thoughts on some of the published work in this area. Alberto Alesina,, Rafael Di Tella, and Robert MacCulloch published a paper in 2004 called “Inequality and happiness: are Europeans and Americans different?”: We study the effect of the level of inequality in society on individual well-being using a total of 123,668 answers to a survey question about “happiness.” We find that individuals have a lower tendency to report themselves happy when inequality is high, even after controlling for individual income, a large set of personal characteristics, and year and country (or, in the case of the US, state) dummies. The effect, however, is more precisely defined statistically in Europe than in the US. In addition, we find striking differences across groups. In Europe, the poor and those on the left of the political spectru
4 0.087470472 251 andrew gelman stats-2010-09-02-Interactions of predictors in a causal model
Introduction: Michael Bader writes: What is the best way to examine interactions of independent variables in a propensity weights framework? Let’s say we are interested in estimating breathing difficulty (measured on a continuous scale) and our main predictor is age of housing. The object is to estimate whether living in housing 20 years or older is associated with breathing difficulty compared counterfactually to those living in housing less than 20 years old; as a secondary question, we want to know whether that effect differs for those in poverty compared to those not in poverty. In our first-stage propensity model, we include whether the respondent lives in poverty. The weights applied to the other covariates in the propensity model are similar to those living in poverty compared to those who are not. Now, can I simply interact the poverty variable with the age of construction variable to look at the interaction of age of housing and poverty on breathing difficulty? My thought is no —
Introduction: There’s a paradigm in applied statistics that goes something like this: 1. There is a scientific or policy question of some theoretical or practical importance. 2. Researchers gather data on relevant outcomes and perform a statistical analysis, ideally leading to a clear conclusion (p less than 0.05, or a strong posterior distribution, or good predictive performance, or high reliability and validity, whatever). 3. This conclusion informs policy. This paradigm has room for positive findings (for example, that a new program is statistically significantly better, or statistically significantly worse than what came before) or negative findings (data are inconclusive, further study is needed), even if negative findings seem less likely to make their way into the textbooks. But what happens when step 2 simply isn’t possible. This came up a few years ago—nearly 10 years ago, now!—with the excellent paper by Donohue and Wolfers which explained why it’s just about impossible to
7 0.072666749 1097 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-03-Libertarians in Space
9 0.06592872 323 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-06-Sociotropic Voting and the Media
12 0.064408667 2086 andrew gelman stats-2013-11-03-How best to compare effects measured in two different time periods?
13 0.062467143 2255 andrew gelman stats-2014-03-19-How Americans vote
14 0.062395986 394 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-05-2010: What happened?
16 0.060672995 359 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-21-Applied Statistics Center miniconference: Statistical sampling in developing countries
18 0.060219903 1732 andrew gelman stats-2013-02-22-Evaluating the impacts of welfare reform?
19 0.059775092 789 andrew gelman stats-2011-07-07-Descriptive statistics, causal inference, and story time
20 0.05931253 2223 andrew gelman stats-2014-02-24-“Edlin’s rule” for routinely scaling down published estimates
topicId topicWeight
[(0, 0.124), (1, -0.022), (2, 0.064), (3, -0.061), (4, -0.017), (5, 0.02), (6, -0.047), (7, -0.014), (8, -0.016), (9, 0.051), (10, -0.052), (11, -0.013), (12, -0.004), (13, 0.02), (14, 0.037), (15, -0.006), (16, 0.018), (17, 0.01), (18, -0.01), (19, 0.009), (20, -0.0), (21, 0.003), (22, -0.034), (23, 0.014), (24, 0.007), (25, 0.02), (26, 0.018), (27, 0.002), (28, 0.015), (29, 0.025), (30, 0.001), (31, 0.019), (32, -0.003), (33, 0.012), (34, -0.019), (35, 0.002), (36, -0.051), (37, 0.027), (38, 0.042), (39, 0.012), (40, -0.019), (41, 0.004), (42, 0.003), (43, 0.011), (44, 0.019), (45, -0.016), (46, 0.003), (47, 0.012), (48, -0.0), (49, -0.008)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 0.98118103 177 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-02-Reintegrating rebels into civilian life: Quasi-experimental evidence from Burundi
Introduction: Michael Gilligan, Eric Mvukiyehe, and Cyrus Samii write : We [Gilligan, Mvukiyehe, and Samii] use original survey data, collected in Burundi in the summer of 2007, to show that a World Bank ex-combatant reintegration program implemented after Burundi’s civil war caused significant economic reintegration for its beneficiaries but that this economic reintegration did not translate into greater political and social reintegration. Previous studies of reintegration programs have found them to be ineffective, but these studies have suffered from selection bias: only ex-combatants who self selected into those programs were studied. We avoid such bias with a quasi-experimental research design made possible by an exogenous bureaucratic failure in the implementation of program. One of the World Bank’s implementing partners delayed implementation by almost a year due to an unforeseen contract dispute. As a result, roughly a third of ex-combatants had their program benefits withheld for reas
Introduction: Paul Alper writes: Unless I missed it, you haven’t commented on the recent article of Michael Bang Peterson [with Daniel Sznycer, Aaron Sell, Leda Cosmides, and John Tooby]. It seems to have been reviewed extensively in the lay press. A typical example is here . This review begins with “If you are physically strong, social science scholars believe they can predict whether or not you are more conservative than other men…Men’s upper-body strength predicts their political opinions on economic redistribution, they write, and they believe that the link may reflect psychological traits that evolved in response to our early ancestral environments and continue to influence behavior today. . . . they surveyed hundreds of people in America, Denmark and Argentina about bicep size, socioeconomic status, and support for economic redistribution.” Further, “Despite the fact that the United States, Denmark and Argentina have very different welfare systems, we still see that — at the psychol
3 0.69166273 149 andrew gelman stats-2010-07-16-Demographics: what variable best predicts a financial crisis?
Introduction: A few weeks ago I wrote about the importance of demographics in political trends . Today I’d like to show you how demographics help predict financial crises. Here are a few examples of countries with major crises. The working-age population in Japan peaked in the 1995 census . The 1995 Financial Crisis in Japan The working-age USA population growth slows down to unprecedented levels in 2008 (see figure below) Financial crisis of 2007-2010 . (Also, notice previous dips in 2001, 1991 and 1981, and consider the list of recessions .) China’s working-age population, age 15 to 64, has grown continuously. The labor pool will peak in 2015 and then decline. There are more charts in Demography and Growth report by the Reserve Bank of Australia: Wikipedia surveys the causes of the financial crisis, such as “liquidity shortfall in the United States banking system caused by the overvaluation of assets”. Oh my! Slightly better than the usu
4 0.69127625 32 andrew gelman stats-2010-05-14-Causal inference in economics
Introduction: Aaron Edlin points me to this issue of the Journal of Economic Perspectives that focuses on statistical methods for causal inference in economics. (Michael Bishop’s page provides some links .) To quickly summarize my reactions to Angrist and Pischke’s book: I pretty much agree with them that the potential-outcomes or natural-experiment approach is the most useful way to think about causality in economics and related fields. My main amendments to Angrist and Pischke would be to recognize that: 1. Modeling is important, especially modeling of interactions . It’s unfortunate to see a debate between experimentalists and modelers. Some experimenters (not Angrist and Pischke) make the mistake of avoiding models: Once they have their experimental data, they check their brains at the door and do nothing but simple differences, not realizing how much more can be learned. Conversely, some modelers are unduly dismissive of experiments and formal observational studies, forgetting t
5 0.69056946 2060 andrew gelman stats-2013-10-13-New issue of Symposium magazine
Introduction: “Where academia meets public life” : The Changing Face of Violence Joel F. Harrington A debate has kicked off among scholars on whether we have become inherently more peaceful. A more important question is whether we actually understand the many forms violence takes. The Professor as Digital Native Interview with Mary Beard Why Central Bank Transparency May Be Overrated Brigitte Granville Be it ever so brilliant, communication in monetary policy is no panacea in today’s world of slow growth, high debt, and fiscal policy uncertainty. When Does Digital Activism Pack a Punch? Philip N. Howard A new project is collecting data to offer insights from digital campaigns around the world. Being ‘Different’ in a World of High Achievers Allison Stevens A Columbia professor writes about the challenges of raising a Down syndrome child – and the mixed reactions among her colleagues. A Grand Illusion Euny Hong How the top French schools remain incubators for the eli
6 0.6874252 1910 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-22-Struggles over the criticism of the “cannabis users and IQ change” paper
7 0.68492526 98 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-19-Further thoughts on happiness and life satisfaction research
8 0.67874908 585 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-22-“How has your thinking changed over the past three years?”
10 0.67123133 828 andrew gelman stats-2011-07-28-Thoughts on Groseclose book on media bias
12 0.66457421 2220 andrew gelman stats-2014-02-22-Quickies
13 0.66388291 1114 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-12-Controversy about average personality differences between men and women
14 0.66226619 845 andrew gelman stats-2011-08-08-How adoption speed affects the abandonment of cultural tastes
15 0.66114205 1558 andrew gelman stats-2012-11-02-Not so fast on levees and seawalls for NY harbor?
16 0.6602751 15 andrew gelman stats-2010-05-03-Public Opinion on Health Care Reform
17 0.65964836 116 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-29-How to grab power in a democracy – in 5 easy non-violent steps
18 0.65747595 1388 andrew gelman stats-2012-06-22-Americans think economy isn’t so bad in their city but is crappy nationally and globally
19 0.65652531 1097 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-03-Libertarians in Space
20 0.65479279 284 andrew gelman stats-2010-09-18-Continuing efforts to justify false “death panels” claim
topicId topicWeight
[(6, 0.013), (15, 0.021), (16, 0.402), (21, 0.018), (24, 0.134), (34, 0.013), (86, 0.017), (89, 0.012), (99, 0.212)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
Introduction: In a discussion of workplace segregation, Philip Cohen posts some graphs that led me to a statistical question. I’ll pose my question below, but first the graphs: In a world of zero segregation of jobs by sex, the top graph above would have a spike at 50% (or, whatever the actual percentage is of women in the labor force) and, in the bottom graph, the pink and blue lines would be in the same place and would look like very steep S curves. The difference between the pink and blue lines represents segregation by job. One thing I wonder is how these graphs would change if we redefine occupation. (For example, is my occupation “mathematical scientist,” “statistician,” “teacher,” “university professor,” “statistics professor,” or “tenured statistics professor”?) Finer or coarser classification would give different results, and I wonder how this would work. This is not at all meant as a criticism of Cohen’s claims, it’s just a statistical question. I’m guessing that
2 0.9886443 1279 andrew gelman stats-2012-04-24-ESPN is looking to hire a research analyst
Introduction: This is somebody’s dream job, I’m sure . . . ESPN is looking for a statistician to join the HR department as a Research Analyst . The job will consist of analytical research and producing statistics about the people that work at ESPN. Topics of interest will include productivity, efficiency, and retention of employees, among other items. In addition to data mining and producing reports, we also field surveys and analyze results. The position is located at the headquarters in Bristol, Connecticut, the same campus where nearly all ESPN shows are produced. ESPN is a Disney company, so discounts and free admission to Disney parks are available for employees. Flexible work arrangements are available, along with working in the New York City office part-time if desired. The role is a relatively new function and will have a high impact very quickly on helping the business function. Statistical software, text books, and any other resource needed to get the job done will be provided. T
3 0.98064399 572 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-14-Desecration of valuable real estate
Introduction: Malecki asks: Is this the worst infographic ever to appear in NYT? USA Today is not something to aspire to. To connect to some of our recent themes , I agree this is a pretty horrible data display. But it’s not bad as a series of images. Considering the competition to be a cartoon or series of photos, these images aren’t so bad. One issue, I think, is that designers get credit for creativity and originality (unusual color combinations! Histogram bars shaped like mosques!) , which is often the opposite of what we want in a clear graph. It’s Martin Amis vs. George Orwell all over again.
4 0.97365242 398 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-06-Quote of the day
Introduction: “A statistical model is usually taken to be summarized by a likelihood, or a likelihood and a prior distribution, but we go an extra step by noting that the parameters of a model are typically batched, and we take this batching as an essential part of the model.”
5 0.96580172 1115 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-12-Where are the larger-than-life athletes?
Introduction: Jonathan Cantor points to this poll estimating rifle-armed QB Tim Tebow as America’s favorite pro athlete: In an ESPN survey of 1,502 Americans age 12 or older, three percent identified Tebow as their favorite professional athlete. Tebow finished in front of Kobe Bryant (2 percent), Aaron Rodgers (1.9 percent), Peyton Manning (1.8 percent), and Tom Brady (1.5 percent). Amusing. What this survey says to me is that there are no super-popular athletes who are active in America today. Which actually sounds about right. No Tiger Woods, no Magic Johnson, Muhammed Ali, John Elway, Pete Rose, Billie Jean King, etc etc. Tebow is an amusing choice, people might as well pick him now while he’s still on top. As a sports celeb, he’s like Bill Lee or the Refrigerator: colorful and a solid pro athlete, but no superstar. When you think about all the colorful superstar athletes of times gone by, it’s perhaps surprising that there’s nobody out there right now to play the role. I supp
6 0.95914149 1487 andrew gelman stats-2012-09-08-Animated drought maps
7 0.95438361 1014 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-16-Visualizations of NYPD stop-and-frisk data
8 0.9531126 528 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-21-Elevator shame is a two-way street
9 0.95233321 1180 andrew gelman stats-2012-02-22-I’m officially no longer a “rogue”
10 0.95118284 1330 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-19-Cross-validation to check missing-data imputation
11 0.9486202 1598 andrew gelman stats-2012-11-30-A graphics talk with no visuals!
12 0.94857758 1659 andrew gelman stats-2013-01-07-Some silly things you (didn’t) miss by not reading the sister blog
13 0.94791603 1025 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-24-Always check your evidence
14 0.94749081 1304 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-06-Picking on Stephen Wolfram
15 0.94476503 700 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-06-Suspicious pattern of too-strong replications of medical research
16 0.9413709 445 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-03-Getting a job in pro sports… as a statistician
17 0.93960452 2 andrew gelman stats-2010-04-23-Modeling heterogenous treatment effects
same-blog 18 0.93572402 177 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-02-Reintegrating rebels into civilian life: Quasi-experimental evidence from Burundi
19 0.93388474 1156 andrew gelman stats-2012-02-06-Bayesian model-building by pure thought: Some principles and examples
20 0.92759198 609 andrew gelman stats-2011-03-13-Coauthorship norms