andrew_gelman_stats andrew_gelman_stats-2011 andrew_gelman_stats-2011-992 knowledge-graph by maker-knowledge-mining
Source: html
Introduction: Mark Palko asks : What are the worst examples of curriculum dead wood? Here’s the background: One of the first things that hit me [Palko] when I started teaching high school math was how much material there was to cover. . . . The most annoying part, though, was the number of topics that could easily have been cut, thus giving the students the time to master the important skills and concepts. The example that really stuck with me was synthetic division, a more concise but less intuitive way of performing polynomial long division. Both of these topics are pretty much useless in daily life but polynomial long division does, at least, give the student some insight into the relationship between polynomials and familiar base-ten numbers. Synthetic division has no such value; it’s just a faster but less interesting way of doing something you’ll never have to do. I started asking hardcore math people — mathematicians, statisticians, physicists, rocket scientists — if they.’d ever u
sentIndex sentText sentNum sentScore
1 Mark Palko asks : What are the worst examples of curriculum dead wood? [sent-1, score-0.308]
2 Here’s the background: One of the first things that hit me [Palko] when I started teaching high school math was how much material there was to cover. [sent-2, score-0.585]
3 The most annoying part, though, was the number of topics that could easily have been cut, thus giving the students the time to master the important skills and concepts. [sent-6, score-0.284]
4 The example that really stuck with me was synthetic division, a more concise but less intuitive way of performing polynomial long division. [sent-7, score-0.8]
5 Both of these topics are pretty much useless in daily life but polynomial long division does, at least, give the student some insight into the relationship between polynomials and familiar base-ten numbers. [sent-8, score-0.857]
6 Synthetic division has no such value; it’s just a faster but less interesting way of doing something you’ll never have to do. [sent-9, score-0.317]
7 I started asking hardcore math people — mathematicians, statisticians, physicists, rocket scientists — if they. [sent-10, score-0.5]
8 By an overwhelming margin, the answer I got was “what’s synthetic division? [sent-12, score-0.46]
9 ” Not only did they not need it; it made so little impression that they forgot ever learning it. [sent-13, score-0.152]
10 Since we need to pare down the curriculum, what you choose to cut? [sent-17, score-0.103]
11 Specifically, what mathematical topics that you learned in school can future generations do without? [sent-18, score-0.425]
12 I’m too distant from the high school curriculum to have much to offer. [sent-19, score-0.673]
13 I think the math in the local elementary school goes a bit too slow, but of course I’d think that. [sent-20, score-0.557]
14 The teachers used to get angry at my sisters when they’d read ahead in the workbook, but by the time I came around, they’d let me curl up with a math book and leave me alone. [sent-22, score-0.378]
15 As long as I kept my mouth shut they had no problem with me. [sent-23, score-0.265]
16 More recently, we spent a year on sabbatical in France (as regular blog readers will recall), and one thing I liked about the public schools there was the uniform national curriculum. [sent-24, score-0.36]
17 It was completely clear what was being covered each year, you could go to a bookstore and get a book such as “L’Année de CP” which had exercises covering the whole year (“CP” is first grade), you could see what was coming next, etc. [sent-25, score-0.416]
18 Maybe it wouldn’t work so well in the higher grades but I liked it for elementary school. [sent-27, score-0.393]
19 Does anyone have thoughts on Mark’s original question about the high school curriculum? [sent-28, score-0.291]
wordName wordTfidf (topN-words)
[('synthetic', 0.389), ('curriculum', 0.308), ('division', 0.253), ('math', 0.204), ('school', 0.199), ('cp', 0.195), ('liked', 0.171), ('elementary', 0.154), ('polynomial', 0.154), ('topics', 0.143), ('palko', 0.118), ('cut', 0.114), ('pare', 0.103), ('rocket', 0.103), ('hardcore', 0.103), ('sisters', 0.103), ('workbook', 0.103), ('bookstore', 0.097), ('ann', 0.097), ('year', 0.096), ('long', 0.093), ('sabbatical', 0.093), ('high', 0.092), ('polynomials', 0.09), ('concise', 0.09), ('started', 0.09), ('mark', 0.088), ('mouth', 0.087), ('exercises', 0.085), ('shut', 0.085), ('generations', 0.083), ('wood', 0.08), ('forgot', 0.08), ('master', 0.078), ('mathematicians', 0.077), ('france', 0.076), ('covering', 0.074), ('intuitive', 0.074), ('distant', 0.074), ('ever', 0.072), ('overwhelming', 0.071), ('angry', 0.071), ('margin', 0.07), ('physicists', 0.069), ('grades', 0.068), ('covered', 0.064), ('faster', 0.064), ('annoying', 0.063), ('useless', 0.063), ('insight', 0.061)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 0.99999994 992 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-05-Deadwood in the math curriculum
Introduction: Mark Palko asks : What are the worst examples of curriculum dead wood? Here’s the background: One of the first things that hit me [Palko] when I started teaching high school math was how much material there was to cover. . . . The most annoying part, though, was the number of topics that could easily have been cut, thus giving the students the time to master the important skills and concepts. The example that really stuck with me was synthetic division, a more concise but less intuitive way of performing polynomial long division. Both of these topics are pretty much useless in daily life but polynomial long division does, at least, give the student some insight into the relationship between polynomials and familiar base-ten numbers. Synthetic division has no such value; it’s just a faster but less interesting way of doing something you’ll never have to do. I started asking hardcore math people — mathematicians, statisticians, physicists, rocket scientists — if they.’d ever u
2 0.21537361 2365 andrew gelman stats-2014-06-09-I hate polynomials
Introduction: A recent discussion with Mark Palko [scroll down to the comments at this link ] reminds me that I think that polynomials are way way overrated, and I think a lot of damage has arisen from the old-time approach of introducing polynomial functions as a canonical example of linear regressions ( for example ). There are very few settings I can think of where it makes sense to fit a general polynomial of degree higher than 2. I think that millions of students have been brainwashed into thinking of these as the canonical functions and that this has caused endless trouble later on. I’m not sure how I’d change the high school math curriculum to deal with this, but I do think it’s an issue.
3 0.17945828 236 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-26-Teaching yourself mathematics
Introduction: Some thoughts from Mark Palko: Of all the subjects a student is likely to encounter after elementary school, mathematics is by far the easiest to teach yourself. . . . What is it that makes math teachers so expendable? . . . At some point all disciplines require the transition from passive to active and that transition can be challenging. In courses like high school history and science, the emphasis on passively acquiring knowledge (yes, I realize that students write essays in history classes and apply formulas in science classes but that represents a relatively small portion of their time and, more importantly, the work those students do is fundamentally different from the day-to-day work done by historians and scientists). By comparison, junior high students playing in an orchestra, writing short stories or solving math problems are almost entirely focused on processes and those processes are essentially the same as those engaged in by professional musicians, writers and mat
4 0.14583154 390 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-02-Fragment of statistical autobiography
Introduction: I studied math and physics at MIT. To be more precise, I started in math as default–ever since I was two years old, I’ve thought of myself as a mathematician, and I always did well in math class, so it seemed like a natural fit. But I was concerned. In high school I’d been in the U.S. Mathematical Olympiad training program, and there I’d met kids who were clearly much much better at math than I was. In retrospect, I don’t think I was as bad as I’d thought at the time: there were 24 kids in the program, and I was probably around #20, if that, but I think a lot of the other kids had more practice working on “math olympiad”-type problems. Maybe I was really something like the tenth-best in the group. Tenth-best or twentieth-best, whatever it was, I reached a crisis of confidence around my sophomore or junior year in college. At MIT, I started right off taking advanced math classes, and somewhere along the way I realized I wasn’t seeing the big picture. I was able to do the homework pr
5 0.14219402 1803 andrew gelman stats-2013-04-14-Why girls do better in school
Introduction: Wayne Folta writes, “In light of your recent blog post on women in higher education, here’s one I just read about on a techie website regarding elementary education”: Why do girls get better grades in elementary school than boys—even when they perform worse on standardized tests? New research . . . suggests that it’s because of their classroom behavior, which may lead teachers to assign girls higher grades than their male counterparts. . . . The study, co-authored by [Christopher] Cornwell and David Mustard at UGA and Jessica Van Parys at Columbia, analyzed data on more than 5,800 students from kindergarten through fifth grade. It examined students’ performance on standardized tests in three categories—reading, math and science-linking test scores to teachers’ assessments of their students’ progress, both academically and more broadly. The data show, for the first time, that gender disparities in teacher grades start early and uniformly favor girls. In every subject area, bo
6 0.13829552 2162 andrew gelman stats-2014-01-08-Belief aggregation
7 0.13659492 529 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-21-“City Opens Inquiry on Grading Practices at a Top-Scoring Bronx School”
8 0.12491895 533 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-23-The scalarization of America
9 0.12187465 2202 andrew gelman stats-2014-02-07-Outrage of the week
10 0.11044045 2104 andrew gelman stats-2013-11-17-Big bad education bureaucracy does big bad things
11 0.10619193 93 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-17-My proposal for making college admissions fairer
12 0.10485367 1318 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-13-Stolen jokes
13 0.10142376 344 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-15-Story time
14 0.099278025 1353 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-30-Question 20 of my final exam for Design and Analysis of Sample Surveys
15 0.097300105 1605 andrew gelman stats-2012-12-04-Write This Book
16 0.09205956 2347 andrew gelman stats-2014-05-25-Why I decided not to be a physicist
17 0.091883026 1864 andrew gelman stats-2013-05-20-Evaluating Columbia University’s Frontiers of Science course
18 0.090150118 1507 andrew gelman stats-2012-09-22-Grade inflation: why weren’t the instructors all giving all A’s already??
19 0.089035586 825 andrew gelman stats-2011-07-27-Grade inflation: why weren’t the instructors all giving all A’s already??
20 0.08580175 606 andrew gelman stats-2011-03-10-It’s no fun being graded on a curve
topicId topicWeight
[(0, 0.156), (1, -0.072), (2, -0.027), (3, 0.026), (4, 0.05), (5, 0.097), (6, 0.074), (7, 0.098), (8, -0.002), (9, 0.001), (10, 0.023), (11, 0.061), (12, -0.036), (13, -0.039), (14, 0.014), (15, -0.036), (16, 0.031), (17, 0.04), (18, -0.025), (19, 0.012), (20, 0.001), (21, 0.008), (22, -0.021), (23, -0.02), (24, 0.036), (25, -0.011), (26, 0.01), (27, 0.01), (28, -0.012), (29, 0.037), (30, -0.028), (31, 0.022), (32, 0.028), (33, -0.032), (34, 0.018), (35, -0.011), (36, -0.029), (37, 0.077), (38, 0.058), (39, 0.023), (40, -0.045), (41, 0.033), (42, 0.004), (43, 0.003), (44, -0.029), (45, -0.004), (46, -0.056), (47, 0.009), (48, -0.027), (49, -0.021)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 0.96126693 992 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-05-Deadwood in the math curriculum
Introduction: Mark Palko asks : What are the worst examples of curriculum dead wood? Here’s the background: One of the first things that hit me [Palko] when I started teaching high school math was how much material there was to cover. . . . The most annoying part, though, was the number of topics that could easily have been cut, thus giving the students the time to master the important skills and concepts. The example that really stuck with me was synthetic division, a more concise but less intuitive way of performing polynomial long division. Both of these topics are pretty much useless in daily life but polynomial long division does, at least, give the student some insight into the relationship between polynomials and familiar base-ten numbers. Synthetic division has no such value; it’s just a faster but less interesting way of doing something you’ll never have to do. I started asking hardcore math people — mathematicians, statisticians, physicists, rocket scientists — if they.’d ever u
2 0.84531486 606 andrew gelman stats-2011-03-10-It’s no fun being graded on a curve
Introduction: Mark Palko points to a news article by Michael Winerip on teacher assessment: No one at the Lab Middle School for Collaborative Studies works harder than Stacey Isaacson, a seventh-grade English and social studies teacher. She is out the door of her Queens home by 6:15 a.m., takes the E train into Manhattan and is standing out front when the school doors are unlocked, at 7. Nights, she leaves her classroom at 5:30. . . . Her principal, Megan Adams, has given her terrific reviews during the two and a half years Ms. Isaacson has been a teacher. . . . The Lab School has selective admissions, and Ms. Isaacson’s students have excelled. Her first year teaching, 65 of 66 scored proficient on the state language arts test, meaning they got 3′s or 4′s; only one scored below grade level with a 2. More than two dozen students from her first two years teaching have gone on to . . . the city’s most competitive high schools. . . . You would think the Department of Education would want to r
3 0.83547467 718 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-18-Should kids be able to bring their own lunches to school?
Introduction: I encountered this news article , “Chicago school bans some lunches brought from home”: At Little Village, most students must take the meals served in the cafeteria or go hungry or both. . . . students are not allowed to pack lunches from home. Unless they have a medical excuse, they must eat the food served in the cafeteria. . . . Such discussions over school lunches and healthy eating echo a larger national debate about the role government should play in individual food choices. “This is such a fundamental infringement on parental responsibility,” said J. Justin Wilson, a senior researcher at the Washington-based Center for Consumer Freedom, which is partially funded by the food industry. . . . For many CPS parents, the idea of forbidding home-packed lunches would be unthinkable. . . . If I had read this two years ago, I’d be at one with J. Justin Wilson and the outraged kids and parents. But last year we spent a sabbatical in Paris, where . . . kids aren’t allowed to bring
4 0.83344859 2104 andrew gelman stats-2013-11-17-Big bad education bureaucracy does big bad things
Introduction: In response to some big new push for testing schoolchildren, Mark Palko writes : The announcement of a new curriculum is invariably followed by a round of hearty round of self congratulations and talk of “keeping standards high” as if adding a slide to a PowerPoint automatically made students better informed. It doesn’t work that way. Adding a topic to the list simply means that students will be exposed to it, not that they will understand or master or retain it. Well put. In my own teaching, I often am tempted to believe that just putting a topic in a homework problem is enough to ensure that students will learn it. But it doesn’t work that way. Even if they manage to somehow struggle through and solve the problem (and many don’t, or they rely on their friends’ solutions), they won’t learn much if they don’t see the connection with everything else they know. I’m reminded of the time, several years ago, that I learned that photocopying an article and filing it was not the
5 0.83141136 93 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-17-My proposal for making college admissions fairer
Introduction: After reading the Rewarding Strivers book , I had some thoughts about how to make the college admissions system more fair to students from varying socioeconomic backgrounds. Instead of boosting up the disadvantaged students, why not pull down the advantaged students? Here’s the idea. Disadvantaged students are defined typically not by a bad thing that they have, but rather by good things that they don’t have: financial resources, a high-quality education, and so forth. In contrast, advantaged students get all sorts of freebies. So here are my suggestions: 1. All high school grades on a 4-point scale (A=4, B=3, etc). No more of this 5-points-for-an-A-in-an-AP course, which gives the ridiculous outcomes of kids graduating with a 4.3 average, not so fair to kids in schools that don’t offer a lot of AP classes. 2. Subtract points for taking the SAT multiple times. A simple rule would be: You can use your highest SAT score, but you lose 50 points for every other time
7 0.81234187 542 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-28-Homework and treatment levels
8 0.79748535 1620 andrew gelman stats-2012-12-12-“Teaching effectiveness” as another dimension in cognitive ability
9 0.78880388 2122 andrew gelman stats-2013-12-03-Objects of the class “Lawrence Summers”: Arne Duncan edition
10 0.78637332 2202 andrew gelman stats-2014-02-07-Outrage of the week
11 0.78424108 1507 andrew gelman stats-2012-09-22-Grade inflation: why weren’t the instructors all giving all A’s already??
12 0.77998668 73 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-08-Observational Epidemiology
13 0.77961528 529 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-21-“City Opens Inquiry on Grading Practices at a Top-Scoring Bronx School”
14 0.7762537 533 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-23-The scalarization of America
15 0.77574718 236 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-26-Teaching yourself mathematics
16 0.77473652 1803 andrew gelman stats-2013-04-14-Why girls do better in school
17 0.77304006 462 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-10-Who’s holding the pen?, The split screen, and other ideas for one-on-one instruction
18 0.77245474 825 andrew gelman stats-2011-07-27-Grade inflation: why weren’t the instructors all giving all A’s already??
19 0.76212335 71 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-07-Pay for an A?
20 0.75424641 452 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-06-Followup questions
topicId topicWeight
[(16, 0.032), (17, 0.013), (21, 0.013), (24, 0.141), (31, 0.276), (40, 0.015), (73, 0.016), (86, 0.051), (95, 0.012), (99, 0.294)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
1 0.97433686 1778 andrew gelman stats-2013-03-27-My talk at the University of Michigan today 4pm
Introduction: Causality and Statistical Learning Andrew Gelman, Statistics and Political Science, Columbia University Wed 27 Mar, 4pm, Betty Ford Auditorium, Ford School of Public Policy Causal inference is central to the social and biomedical sciences. There are unresolved debates about the meaning of causality and the methods that should be used to measure it. As a statistician, I am trained to say that randomized experiments are a gold standard, yet I have spent almost all my applied career analyzing observational data. In this talk we shall consider various approaches to causal reasoning from the perspective of an applied statistician who recognizes the importance of causal identification yet must learn from available information. Two relevant papers are here and here .
2 0.93143165 1127 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-18-The Fixie Bike Index
Introduction: Where are the fixed-gear bike riders? Rohin Dhar explains : At Priceonomics, in order to build our bicycle price guide, we measure what kind of used bikes people are trying to sell and the quantity sold in any city. By mining our database of 1.3 million bicycle listings, we can tell what are the largest markets for used bicycles, how the prices vary by region, and where people who prize fixed gear bikes live. Fixies (fixed gear bikes) are considered to be a strong indicator of hipsterness. For those unfamiliar, a fixed gear bike requires riding in a single gear and the only way to stop the bike is to pedal backwards to help skid the bike to a halt. You can’t “coast” on a fixie; when you are biking downhill, your pedals will keep moving so you better keep pedaling too. Because of the minimalism of this fixed gear system, the bikes tend to be aesthetically pleasing but somewhat challenging to ride. . . . In short, fixed gear bikes = hipsters, and New York boroug
3 0.93025076 2192 andrew gelman stats-2014-01-30-History is too important to be left to the history professors, Part 2
Introduction: Completely non-gay historian Niall Ferguson, a man who we can be sure would never be caught at a ballet or a poetry reading, informs us that the British decision to enter the first world war on the side of France and Belgium was “the biggest error in modern history.” Ummm, here are a few bigger errors: The German decision to invade Russia in 1941. The Japanese decision to attack America in 1941. Oh yeah , the German decision to invade Belgium in 1914. The Russian decision to invade Afghanistan in 1981 doesn’t look like such a great decision either. And it wasn’t so smart for Saddam Hussein to invade Kuwait, but maybe the countries involved were too small for this to count as “the biggest error in modern history.” It’s striking that, in considering the biggest error in modern history, Ferguson omits all these notorious acts of aggression (bombing Pearl Harbor, leading to the destruction of much of your country, that was pretty bad, huh?), and decides that the worst
same-blog 4 0.92423946 992 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-05-Deadwood in the math curriculum
Introduction: Mark Palko asks : What are the worst examples of curriculum dead wood? Here’s the background: One of the first things that hit me [Palko] when I started teaching high school math was how much material there was to cover. . . . The most annoying part, though, was the number of topics that could easily have been cut, thus giving the students the time to master the important skills and concepts. The example that really stuck with me was synthetic division, a more concise but less intuitive way of performing polynomial long division. Both of these topics are pretty much useless in daily life but polynomial long division does, at least, give the student some insight into the relationship between polynomials and familiar base-ten numbers. Synthetic division has no such value; it’s just a faster but less interesting way of doing something you’ll never have to do. I started asking hardcore math people — mathematicians, statisticians, physicists, rocket scientists — if they.’d ever u
5 0.90504897 242 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-29-The Subtle Micro-Effects of Peacekeeping
Introduction: Eric Mvukiyehe and Cyrus Samii write : We [Mvukiyehe and Samii] use original survey data and administrative data to test a theory of the micro-level impacts of peacekeeping. The theory proposes that through the creation of local security bubbles and also through direct assistance, peacekeeping deployments contribute to economic and social revitalization that may contribute to more durable peace. This theory guides the design of current United Nations peacekeeping operations, and has been proposed as one of the explanations for peacekeeping’s well-documented association with more durable peace. Our evidence paint a complex picture that deviates substantially from the theory. We do not find evidence for local security bubbles around deployment base areas, and we do not find that deployments were substantial contributors to local social infrastructure. In addition, we find a negative relationship between deployment basing locations and NGO contributions to social infrastructure.
7 0.88028157 682 andrew gelman stats-2011-04-27-“The ultimate left-wing novel”
8 0.87475735 1391 andrew gelman stats-2012-06-25-A question about the Tiger Mom: what if she’d had boys instead of girls?
10 0.8725211 1863 andrew gelman stats-2013-05-19-Prose is paragraphs, prose is sentences
11 0.87184083 1995 andrew gelman stats-2013-08-23-“I mean, what exact buttons do I have to hit?”
12 0.87107939 925 andrew gelman stats-2011-09-26-Ethnicity and Population Structure in Personal Naming Networks
13 0.86888874 2207 andrew gelman stats-2014-02-11-My talks in Bristol this Wed and London this Thurs
14 0.84246814 1846 andrew gelman stats-2013-05-07-Like Casper the ghost, Niall Ferguson is not only white. He is also very, very adorable.
16 0.8332262 599 andrew gelman stats-2011-03-03-Two interesting posts elsewhere on graphics
17 0.83079398 1880 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-02-Flame bait
18 0.83032691 1673 andrew gelman stats-2013-01-15-My talk last night at the visualization meetup
19 0.83029097 950 andrew gelman stats-2011-10-10-“Causality is almost always in doubt”
20 0.83022147 2365 andrew gelman stats-2014-06-09-I hate polynomials