andrew_gelman_stats andrew_gelman_stats-2013 andrew_gelman_stats-2013-1905 knowledge-graph by maker-knowledge-mining
Source: html
Introduction: This post is by Phil. A little over three years ago I wrote a post about exercise and weight loss in which I described losing a fair amount of weight due to (I believe) an exercise regime, with no effort to change my diet; this contradicted the prediction of studies that had recently been released. The comment thread on that post is quite interesting: a lot of people had had similar experiences — losing weight, or keeping it off, with an exercise program that includes very short periods of exercise at maximal intensity — while other people expressed some skepticism about my claims. Some commenters said that I risked injury; others said it was too early to judge anything because my weight loss might not last. The people who predicted injury were right: running the curve during a 200m sprint a month or two after that post, I strained my Achilles tendon. Nothing really serious, but it did keep me off the track for a couple of months, and rather than go back to sprinting I switched t
sentIndex sentText sentNum sentScore
1 A little over three years ago I wrote a post about exercise and weight loss in which I described losing a fair amount of weight due to (I believe) an exercise regime, with no effort to change my diet; this contradicted the prediction of studies that had recently been released. [sent-2, score-2.245]
2 The comment thread on that post is quite interesting: a lot of people had had similar experiences — losing weight, or keeping it off, with an exercise program that includes very short periods of exercise at maximal intensity — while other people expressed some skepticism about my claims. [sent-3, score-0.853]
3 Some commenters said that I risked injury; others said it was too early to judge anything because my weight loss might not last. [sent-4, score-0.631]
4 People who suggested my weight would return were wrong, at least so far. [sent-8, score-0.509]
5 During that time I’ve gotten my heart rate close to my maximum twice a week or more in most weeks, by riding up steep hills as hard as I can. [sent-10, score-0.559]
6 Of course I’m also getting other exercise on my bike — I ride for hours sometimes — but for reasons described in that previous post I think it’s the high-intensity exercise that has a big effect on my weight. [sent-13, score-1.042]
7 A few legs of the route are pretty intimidating — long, steep climbs at fairly high elevation — so after signing up for the trip I started training more: getting an hour ride in before work, riding farther and harder on weekends, etc. [sent-15, score-0.69]
8 After a couple of months I was a stronger biker than ever, but my weight was still around 193-195 pounds. [sent-16, score-0.526]
9 I’ve never been concerned about weight loss per se; I think of it as an unintended (but welcome) consequence of my activities. [sent-18, score-0.695]
10 But about a month and a half after I started training for my trip I was chatting with a biking friend who is much faster and fitter than me, and who weighs even less than Taylor Phinney in spite of being almost my height, and he suggested I lose some weight before my Pyrenees ride. [sent-20, score-0.825]
11 I told him that although it would be great to haul 10 fewer pounds of fat over every mountain with me, I wasn’t willing to diet to do it. [sent-21, score-0.543]
12 But, upon reflection, I did decide to try to do two things to see if I could lose weight before my big ride: (1) reach my max heart rate 3 or 4 days per week instead of 2, and (2) weigh myself every morning. [sent-23, score-0.99]
13 So for the first time in my life I had a weight loss goal! [sent-25, score-0.631]
14 That was about 10 weeks ago, and I now weigh under 188 pounds, so I lost about 6 pounds in 10 weeks. [sent-26, score-0.506]
15 I’m about 20 pounds lighter than I was three years ago when I put maximum-intensity intervals back into my routine. [sent-28, score-0.623]
16 I seem to have stabilized, with no change in the past two weeks, which is too bad since I’d love to have gotten down to my playing weight from 16 years ago. [sent-29, score-0.591]
17 In conclusion: I continue to believe that studies that claim that exercise doesn’t lead to weight loss are wrong. [sent-31, score-0.975]
18 For me, when it comes to weight it doesn’t seem to matter whether the intense exercise is in the form of running or biking. [sent-36, score-0.801]
19 To try to discourage a theme that cropped up in the previous post, three years ago: I am _not_ claiming that high-intensity exercise is part of the solution of America’s obesity problem, or anything of that sort. [sent-37, score-0.496]
20 I will probably slip back to two days a week when I get back from my trip, in fact, in which case I expect my weight to climb back up in to the low 190s. [sent-39, score-0.889]
wordName wordTfidf (topN-words)
[('weight', 0.457), ('exercise', 0.344), ('pounds', 0.313), ('loss', 0.174), ('fat', 0.151), ('trip', 0.149), ('ride', 0.147), ('phinney', 0.115), ('stabilized', 0.115), ('bike', 0.113), ('weeks', 0.107), ('pyrenees', 0.104), ('heart', 0.102), ('steep', 0.098), ('heavier', 0.098), ('post', 0.094), ('week', 0.094), ('cyclist', 0.091), ('ago', 0.089), ('weigh', 0.086), ('three', 0.084), ('injury', 0.082), ('diet', 0.079), ('taylor', 0.078), ('riding', 0.078), ('losing', 0.071), ('back', 0.069), ('months', 0.069), ('days', 0.068), ('years', 0.068), ('gotten', 0.066), ('body', 0.065), ('per', 0.064), ('effort', 0.063), ('low', 0.063), ('rate', 0.062), ('sports', 0.059), ('maximum', 0.059), ('training', 0.058), ('lose', 0.057), ('harder', 0.056), ('enjoy', 0.055), ('suggested', 0.052), ('touching', 0.052), ('cycling', 0.052), ('uphill', 0.052), ('mockable', 0.052), ('legs', 0.052), ('elevation', 0.052), ('fitter', 0.052)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 1.0000005 1905 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-18-There are no fat sprinters
Introduction: This post is by Phil. A little over three years ago I wrote a post about exercise and weight loss in which I described losing a fair amount of weight due to (I believe) an exercise regime, with no effort to change my diet; this contradicted the prediction of studies that had recently been released. The comment thread on that post is quite interesting: a lot of people had had similar experiences — losing weight, or keeping it off, with an exercise program that includes very short periods of exercise at maximal intensity — while other people expressed some skepticism about my claims. Some commenters said that I risked injury; others said it was too early to judge anything because my weight loss might not last. The people who predicted injury were right: running the curve during a 200m sprint a month or two after that post, I strained my Achilles tendon. Nothing really serious, but it did keep me off the track for a couple of months, and rather than go back to sprinting I switched t
2 0.45398784 2022 andrew gelman stats-2013-09-13-You heard it here first: Intense exercise can suppress appetite
Introduction: This post is by Phil Price. The New York Times recently ran an article entitled “How Exercise Can Help Us Eat Less,” which begins with this: “Strenuous exercise seems to dull the urge to eat afterward better than gentler workouts, several new studies show, adding to a growing body of science suggesting that intense exercise may have unique benefits.” The article is based on a couple of recent studies in which moderately overweight volunteers participated in different types of exercise, and had their food intake monitored at a subsequent meal. The article also says “[The volunteers] also displayed significantly lower levels of the hormone ghrelin, which is known to stimulate appetite, and elevated levels of both blood lactate and blood sugar, which have been shown to lessen the drive to eat, after the most vigorous interval session than after the other workouts. And the appetite-suppressing effect of the highly intense intervals lingered into the next day, according to food diarie
Introduction: I read this front-page New York Times article and was immediately suspicious. Here’s the story (from reporter Gina Kolata): Could exercise actually be bad for some healthy people? A well-known group of researchers, including one who helped write the scientific paper justifying national guidelines that promote exercise for all, say the answer may be a qualified yes. By analyzing data from six rigorous exercise studies involving 1,687 people, the group found that about 10 percent actually got worse on at least one of the measures related to heart disease: blood pressure and levels of insulin, HDL cholesterol or triglycerides. About 7 percent got worse on at least two measures. And the researchers say they do not know why. “It is bizarre,” said Claude Bouchard, lead author of the paper , published on Wednesday in the journal PLoS One . . . Dr. Michael Lauer, director of the Division of Cardiovascular Sciences at the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, the lead federal
4 0.17097455 1681 andrew gelman stats-2013-01-19-Participate in a short survey about the weight of evidence provided by statistics
Introduction: Richard Morey writes: Rink Hoekstra and I are undertaking some research to explore how people use classical statistical results to evaluate the weight of evidence. Bayesians often critique classical techniques for being difficult to interpret in terms of what scientists want to know, but there is clearly information in the statistics themselves. We wonder how people extract that information. Below is our official announcement; it would be great if you could let people on your blog know about the survey, as we want to get a wide variety of statistical users to take the survey. Announcement follows: Empirical science is grounded on the belief that data can be used as evidence. The convincingness of data — the “weight” of the evidence they provide — is crucial to deciding between rival scientific positions. In situations with no uncertainty, reasoning about evidence is often straightforward; in practice, however, most conclusions from data involve uncertainty. In these situations,
5 0.14377168 1341 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-24-Question 14 of my final exam for Design and Analysis of Sample Surveys
Introduction: 14. A public health survey of elderly Americans includes many questions, including “How many hours per week did you exercise in your most active years as a young adult?” and also several questions about current mobility and health status. Response rates are high for the questions about recent activities and status, but there is a lot of nonresponse for the question on past activity. You are considering imputing the missing values on the question, “How many hours per week did you exercise in your most active years as a young adult?” Which of the following statements are basically correct? (Indicate all that apply.) (a) If done reasonably well, imputation is preferred to available-case and complete-case analysis. (b) If you do impute, you should also present the available-case and complete-case analysis and analyze how the imputed estimates differ. (c) It is OK to include current health status variables as predictors in a model imputing past activities: anything that adds informati
6 0.13016483 1239 andrew gelman stats-2012-04-01-A randomized trial of the set-point diet
7 0.12046333 1163 andrew gelman stats-2012-02-12-Meta-analysis, game theory, and incentives to do replicable research
8 0.11387235 1741 andrew gelman stats-2013-02-27-Thin scientists say it’s unhealthy to be fat
9 0.11139362 341 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-14-Confusion about continuous probability densities
10 0.11001211 154 andrew gelman stats-2010-07-18-Predictive checks for hierarchical models
11 0.10547766 526 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-19-“If it saves the life of a single child…” and other nonsense
12 0.10239981 2313 andrew gelman stats-2014-04-30-Seth Roberts
13 0.097789019 569 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-12-Get the Data
14 0.090989105 1897 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-13-When’s that next gamma-ray blast gonna come, already?
15 0.090839386 583 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-21-An interesting assignment for statistical graphics
16 0.089222446 2257 andrew gelman stats-2014-03-20-The candy weighing demonstration, or, the unwisdom of crowds
17 0.089128368 1502 andrew gelman stats-2012-09-19-Scalability in education
18 0.083235733 2182 andrew gelman stats-2014-01-22-Spell-checking example demonstrates key aspects of Bayesian data analysis
19 0.082650088 182 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-03-Nebraska never looked so appealing: anatomy of a zombie attack. Oops, I mean a recession.
20 0.08169578 2006 andrew gelman stats-2013-09-03-Evaluating evidence from published research
topicId topicWeight
[(0, 0.164), (1, -0.073), (2, 0.017), (3, -0.004), (4, 0.023), (5, -0.007), (6, 0.069), (7, 0.013), (8, 0.031), (9, -0.058), (10, -0.036), (11, 0.002), (12, 0.026), (13, 0.005), (14, -0.019), (15, 0.041), (16, 0.077), (17, -0.021), (18, 0.009), (19, 0.044), (20, -0.006), (21, 0.062), (22, -0.059), (23, 0.045), (24, -0.013), (25, 0.045), (26, -0.042), (27, -0.038), (28, 0.056), (29, -0.002), (30, -0.037), (31, -0.005), (32, -0.04), (33, -0.032), (34, 0.025), (35, -0.076), (36, -0.008), (37, 0.083), (38, 0.024), (39, -0.073), (40, -0.067), (41, -0.05), (42, 0.005), (43, -0.035), (44, 0.058), (45, -0.015), (46, 0.017), (47, -0.035), (48, -0.056), (49, 0.019)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 0.95835644 1905 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-18-There are no fat sprinters
Introduction: This post is by Phil. A little over three years ago I wrote a post about exercise and weight loss in which I described losing a fair amount of weight due to (I believe) an exercise regime, with no effort to change my diet; this contradicted the prediction of studies that had recently been released. The comment thread on that post is quite interesting: a lot of people had had similar experiences — losing weight, or keeping it off, with an exercise program that includes very short periods of exercise at maximal intensity — while other people expressed some skepticism about my claims. Some commenters said that I risked injury; others said it was too early to judge anything because my weight loss might not last. The people who predicted injury were right: running the curve during a 200m sprint a month or two after that post, I strained my Achilles tendon. Nothing really serious, but it did keep me off the track for a couple of months, and rather than go back to sprinting I switched t
2 0.91301399 2022 andrew gelman stats-2013-09-13-You heard it here first: Intense exercise can suppress appetite
Introduction: This post is by Phil Price. The New York Times recently ran an article entitled “How Exercise Can Help Us Eat Less,” which begins with this: “Strenuous exercise seems to dull the urge to eat afterward better than gentler workouts, several new studies show, adding to a growing body of science suggesting that intense exercise may have unique benefits.” The article is based on a couple of recent studies in which moderately overweight volunteers participated in different types of exercise, and had their food intake monitored at a subsequent meal. The article also says “[The volunteers] also displayed significantly lower levels of the hormone ghrelin, which is known to stimulate appetite, and elevated levels of both blood lactate and blood sugar, which have been shown to lessen the drive to eat, after the most vigorous interval session than after the other workouts. And the appetite-suppressing effect of the highly intense intervals lingered into the next day, according to food diarie
3 0.73337549 1239 andrew gelman stats-2012-04-01-A randomized trial of the set-point diet
Introduction: Someone pointed me to this forthcoming article in the journal Nutrition by J. F. Lee et al. It looks pretty cool. I’m glad that someone went to the effort of performing this careful study. Regular readers will know that I’ve been waiting for this one for awhile. In case you can’t read the article through the paywall, here’s the abstract: Background: Under a widely-accepted theory of caloric balance, any individual has a set-point weight and will find it uncomfortable and typically unsustainable to keep his or her weight below that point. Set-points have evidently been increasing over the past few decades in the United States and other countries, leading to a public-health crisis of obesity. In an n=1 study, Roberts (2004, 2006) proposed an intervention to lower the set-point via daily consumption of unflavored sugar water or vegetable oil. Objective: To evaluate weight-loss outcomes under the diet proposed by Roberts (2004, 2006). Design: Randomized clinica
4 0.71719474 731 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-26-Lottery probability update
Introduction: It was reported last year that the national lottery of Israel featured the exact same 6 numbers (out of 45) twice in the same month, and statistics professor Isaac Meilijson of Tel Aviv University was quoted as saying that “the incident of six numbers repeating themselves within a month is an event of once in 10,000 years.” I shouldn’t mock when it comes to mathematics–after all, I proved a false theorem once! (Or, to be precise, my collaborator and I published a false claim which we thought we’d proved, thus we thought was a theorem.) So let me retract the mockery and move, first to the mathematics and then to the statistics. First, how many possibilities are there in pick 6 out of 45? It’s (45*44*43*42*41*40)/6! = 8,145,060. Let’s call this number N. Second, what’s the probability that the same numbers repeat in a single calendar month? I’ve been told that the Israeli lottery has 2 draws per week, That’s 104/12=8.67 draws per month. Or maybe they skip some holiday
Introduction: Alexander at GiveWell writes : The Disease Control Priorities in Developing Countries (DCP2), a major report funded by the Gates Foundation . . . provides an estimate of $3.41 per disability-adjusted life-year (DALY) for the cost-effectiveness of soil-transmitted-helminth (STH) treatment, implying that STH treatment is one of the most cost-effective interventions for global health. In investigating this figure, we have corresponded, over a period of months, with six scholars who had been directly or indirectly involved in the production of the estimate. Eventually, we were able to obtain the spreadsheet that was used to generate the $3.41/DALY estimate. That spreadsheet contains five separate errors that, when corrected, shift the estimated cost effectiveness of deworming from $3.41 to $326.43. [I think they mean to say $300 -- ed.] We came to this conclusion a year after learning that the DCP2’s published cost-effectiveness estimate for schistosomiasis treatment – another kind of
6 0.70559615 514 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-13-News coverage of statistical issues…how did I do?
9 0.69806063 1897 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-13-When’s that next gamma-ray blast gonna come, already?
10 0.69425839 67 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-03-More on that Dartmouth health care study
11 0.69281346 179 andrew gelman stats-2010-08-03-An Olympic size swimming pool full of lithium water
12 0.69112688 1945 andrew gelman stats-2013-07-18-“How big is your chance of dying in an ordinary play?”
13 0.68860149 68 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-03-…pretty soon you’re talking real money.
14 0.688263 354 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-19-There’s only one Amtrak
15 0.68597406 457 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-07-Whassup with phantom-limb treatment?
16 0.68374377 2341 andrew gelman stats-2014-05-20-plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose
17 0.67800188 2352 andrew gelman stats-2014-05-29-When you believe in things that you don’t understand
18 0.67704016 1964 andrew gelman stats-2013-08-01-Non-topical blogging
20 0.67267877 1471 andrew gelman stats-2012-08-27-Why do we never see a full decision analysis for a clinical trial?
topicId topicWeight
[(16, 0.087), (21, 0.023), (24, 0.122), (53, 0.257), (63, 0.014), (72, 0.023), (76, 0.02), (81, 0.013), (85, 0.015), (86, 0.014), (89, 0.011), (95, 0.018), (99, 0.246)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
1 0.96933961 1589 andrew gelman stats-2012-11-25-Life as a blogger: the emails just get weirder and weirder
Introduction: In the email the other day, subject line “Casting blogger, writer, journalist to host cable series”: Hi there Andrew, I’m casting a male journalist, writer, blogger, documentary filmmaker or comedian with a certain type personality for a television pilot along with production company, Pipeline39. See below: A certain type of character – no cockiness, no ego, a person who is smart, savvy, dry humor, but someone who isn’t imposing, who can infiltrate these organizations. This person will be hosting his own show and covering alternative lifestyles and secret societies around the world. If you’re interested in hearing more or would like to be considered for this project, please email me a photo and a bio of yourself, along with contact information. I’ll respond to you ASAP. I’m looking forward to hearing from you. *** Casting Producer (646) ***.**** ***@gmail.com I was with them until I got to the “no ego” part. . . . Also, I don’t think I could infiltrate any org
Introduction: Tapen Sinha writes: Living in Mexico, I have been witness to many strange (and beautiful) things. Perhaps the strangest happened during the first outbreak of A(H1N1) in Mexico City. We had our university closed, football (soccer) was played in empty stadiums (or should it be stadia) because the government feared a spread of the virus. The Metro was operating and so were the private/public buses and taxis. Since the university was closed, we took the opportunity to collect data on facemask use in the public transport systems. It was a simple (but potentially deadly!) exercise in first hand statistical data collection that we teach our students (Although I must admit that I did not dare sending my research assistant to collect data – what if she contracted the virus?). I believe it was a unique experiment never to be repeated. The paper appeared in the journal Health Policy. From the abstract: At the height of the influenza epidemic in Mexico City in the spring of 2009, the f
3 0.95311219 1856 andrew gelman stats-2013-05-14-GPstuff: Bayesian Modeling with Gaussian Processes
Introduction: I think it’s part of my duty as a blogger to intersperse, along with the steady flow of jokes, rants, and literary criticism, some material that will actually be useful to you. So here goes. Jarno Vanhatalo, Jaakko Riihimäki, Jouni Hartikainen, Pasi Jylänki, Ville Tolvanen, and Aki Vehtari write : The GPstuff toolbox is a versatile collection of Gaussian process models and computational tools required for Bayesian inference. The tools include, among others, various inference methods, sparse approximations and model assessment methods. We can actually now fit Gaussian processes in Stan . But for big problems (or even moderately-sized problems), full Bayes can be slow. GPstuff uses EP, which is faster. At some point we’d like to implement EP in Stan. (Right now we’re working with Dave Blei to implement VB.) GPstuff really works. I saw Aki use it to fit a nonparametric version of the Bangladesh well-switching example in ARM. He was sitting in his office and just whip
4 0.95015359 1677 andrew gelman stats-2013-01-16-Greenland is one tough town
Introduction: Americans (including me) don’t know much about other countries. Jeff Lax sent me to this blog post by Myrddin pointing out that Belgium has a higher murder rate than the rest of Western Europe. I have no particular take on this, but it’s a good reminder that other countries differ from each other. Here in the U.S., we tend to think all western European countries are the same, all eastern European countries are the same, etc. In reality, Sweden is not Finland . P.S. According to the Wiki , Greenland is one tough town. I guess there’s nothing much to do out there but watch satellite TV, chew the blubber, and kill people.
5 0.93616813 1468 andrew gelman stats-2012-08-24-Multilevel modeling and instrumental variables
Introduction: Terence Teo writes: I was wondering if multilevel models can be used as an alternative to 2SLS or IV models to deal with (i) endogeneity and (ii) selection problems. More concretely, I am trying to assess the impact of investment treaties on foreign investment. Aside from the fact that foreign investment is correlated over time, it may be the case that countries that already receive sufficient amounts of foreign investment need not sign treaties, and countries that sign treaties are those that need foreign investment in the first place. Countries thus “select” into treatment; treaty signing is non-random. As such, I argue that to properly estimate the impact of treaties on investment, we must model the determinants of treaty signing. I [Teo] am currently modeling this as two separate models: (1) regress predictors on likelihood of treaty signing, (2) regress treaty (with interactions, etc) on investment (I’ve thought of using propensity score matching for this part of the model)
same-blog 6 0.92824709 1905 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-18-There are no fat sprinters
7 0.92272747 46 andrew gelman stats-2010-05-21-Careers, one-hit wonders, and an offer of a free book
8 0.91807759 1802 andrew gelman stats-2013-04-14-Detecting predictability in complex ecosystems
9 0.91437972 413 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-14-Statistics of food consumption
10 0.90934187 991 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-04-Insecure researchers aren’t sharing their data
11 0.90341091 733 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-27-Another silly graph
12 0.90142012 1902 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-17-Job opening at new “big data” consulting firm!
13 0.89730674 1047 andrew gelman stats-2011-12-08-I Am Too Absolutely Heteroskedastic for This Probit Model
14 0.89683354 2022 andrew gelman stats-2013-09-13-You heard it here first: Intense exercise can suppress appetite
16 0.88681483 495 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-31-“Threshold earners” and economic inequality
17 0.87097114 880 andrew gelman stats-2011-08-30-Annals of spam
18 0.85820401 547 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-31-Using sample size in the prior distribution
19 0.85231996 354 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-19-There’s only one Amtrak
20 0.85162008 2067 andrew gelman stats-2013-10-18-EP and ABC