andrew_gelman_stats andrew_gelman_stats-2013 andrew_gelman_stats-2013-1715 knowledge-graph by maker-knowledge-mining
Source: html
Introduction: A few years ago I watched a bunch of Speed Racer cartoons with Phil in a movie theater in the early 90s. These were low-budget Japanese cartoons from the 60s that we loved as kids. From my adult perspective, the best parts were during the characters’ long drives, where you could see Japanese industrial scenes in the background. Similarly, sometimes the most interesting aspect of a book or article is not its overt content but rather its unexamined assumptions. I was reminded of this today when reading the Times this morning. In an interesting column reviewing recent research on happiness (marred only by his decision not to interview any psychology researchers; after all, they’re the academic experts on the topic), Adam Davidson writes : So much debate about government policy is based on economic statistics that come out of the market. But the goal of government is not just to maximize revenue. This perked me up. Not just to maximize revenue? This has to be a sign of the
sentIndex sentText sentNum sentScore
1 A few years ago I watched a bunch of Speed Racer cartoons with Phil in a movie theater in the early 90s. [sent-1, score-0.529]
2 These were low-budget Japanese cartoons from the 60s that we loved as kids. [sent-2, score-0.345]
3 From my adult perspective, the best parts were during the characters’ long drives, where you could see Japanese industrial scenes in the background. [sent-3, score-0.288]
4 Similarly, sometimes the most interesting aspect of a book or article is not its overt content but rather its unexamined assumptions. [sent-4, score-0.493]
5 But the goal of government is not just to maximize revenue. [sent-7, score-0.53]
6 This has to be a sign of the times, the idea that anyone would think that “maximizing revenue” is the main goal of government, to the extent that it would be considered necessary to say it’s not the only goal. [sent-10, score-0.225]
7 My point here is not to make some sort of political statement—it’s not about left or right, nor is it a criticism of Davidson. [sent-11, score-0.071]
8 It’s more of a comment on the unexamined assumptions of our political discourse that someone would say this at all, especially in such a matter-of-fact tone, as if it’s some sort of standard belief that maximizing revenue is the goal of government. [sent-12, score-1.177]
9 I’m also not so happy about this line: There is no evidence, [economist Justin] Wolfers says, that an artist would be happier if she became a hedge-fund trader. [sent-16, score-0.261]
10 I think this is misleading because it implies an ability to switch between low and high-paying jobs. [sent-17, score-0.229]
11 It’s not clear to me how relevant Justin’s comparison is, given that “becoming a hedge-fund trader” is not an option for most people. [sent-18, score-0.075]
12 Lots of people can’t find jobs at all, and only a very small fraction of people can find jobs that are so well-paying. [sent-19, score-0.366]
13 So Justin is, in effect, talking about a very rarefied group, for which the relation between income and happiness might be much different from that of the general population. [sent-20, score-0.236]
wordName wordTfidf (topN-words)
[('revenue', 0.327), ('justin', 0.251), ('cartoons', 0.249), ('unexamined', 0.23), ('maximizing', 0.224), ('japanese', 0.204), ('maximize', 0.198), ('government', 0.176), ('happiness', 0.162), ('goal', 0.156), ('jobs', 0.14), ('marred', 0.125), ('overt', 0.125), ('trader', 0.115), ('wolfers', 0.109), ('davidson', 0.106), ('artist', 0.104), ('theater', 0.102), ('industrial', 0.1), ('watched', 0.1), ('discourse', 0.099), ('drives', 0.099), ('scenes', 0.099), ('adam', 0.096), ('loved', 0.096), ('tone', 0.092), ('adult', 0.089), ('happier', 0.088), ('characters', 0.087), ('fraction', 0.086), ('times', 0.085), ('reviewing', 0.084), ('switch', 0.083), ('speed', 0.081), ('becoming', 0.08), ('weird', 0.078), ('movie', 0.078), ('implies', 0.075), ('option', 0.075), ('relation', 0.074), ('interview', 0.073), ('phil', 0.071), ('political', 0.071), ('misleading', 0.071), ('belief', 0.07), ('aspect', 0.07), ('sign', 0.069), ('became', 0.069), ('interesting', 0.068), ('debate', 0.067)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 1.0 1715 andrew gelman stats-2013-02-09-Thomas Hobbes would be spinning in his grave
Introduction: A few years ago I watched a bunch of Speed Racer cartoons with Phil in a movie theater in the early 90s. These were low-budget Japanese cartoons from the 60s that we loved as kids. From my adult perspective, the best parts were during the characters’ long drives, where you could see Japanese industrial scenes in the background. Similarly, sometimes the most interesting aspect of a book or article is not its overt content but rather its unexamined assumptions. I was reminded of this today when reading the Times this morning. In an interesting column reviewing recent research on happiness (marred only by his decision not to interview any psychology researchers; after all, they’re the academic experts on the topic), Adam Davidson writes : So much debate about government policy is based on economic statistics that come out of the market. But the goal of government is not just to maximize revenue. This perked me up. Not just to maximize revenue? This has to be a sign of the
2 0.13034546 486 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-26-Age and happiness: The pattern isn’t as clear as you might think
Introduction: A couple people pointed me to this recent news article which discusses “why, beyond middle age, people get happier as they get older.” Here’s the story: When people start out on adult life, they are, on average, pretty cheerful. Things go downhill from youth to middle age until they reach a nadir commonly known as the mid-life crisis. So far, so familiar. The surprising part happens after that. Although as people move towards old age they lose things they treasure–vitality, mental sharpness and looks–they also gain what people spend their lives pursuing: happiness. This curious finding has emerged from a new branch of economics that seeks a more satisfactory measure than money of human well-being. Conventional economics uses money as a proxy for utility–the dismal way in which the discipline talks about happiness. But some economists, unconvinced that there is a direct relationship between money and well-being, have decided to go to the nub of the matter and measure happiness i
3 0.12479082 1305 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-07-Happy news on happiness; what can we believe?
Introduction: Sharon Jayson writes : The conventional wisdom that’s developed over the past few decades — based on early research — has said parents are less happy, more depressed and have less-satisfying marriages than their childless counterparts. But now, two new studies presented as part of the Population Association of America’s annual meeting suggest that earlier findings in several studies weren’t so clear-cut and may, in fact, be flawed. The newer analyses presented this week use analytical methods based on data from almost 130,000 adults around the globe — including more than 52,000 parents — and the conclusions aren’t so grim. They say that parents today may indeed be happier than non-parents and that parental happiness levels — while they do drop — don’t dip below the levels they were before having children. . . . The other study, of some 120,000 adults from two nationally representative surveys between 1972-2008, finds that parents were indeed less happy than non-parents in the d
4 0.11462191 98 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-19-Further thoughts on happiness and life satisfaction research
Introduction: As part of my continuing research project with Grazia and Roberto, I’ve been reading papers on happiness and life satisfaction research. I’ll share with you my thoughts on some of the published work in this area. Alberto Alesina,, Rafael Di Tella, and Robert MacCulloch published a paper in 2004 called “Inequality and happiness: are Europeans and Americans different?”: We study the effect of the level of inequality in society on individual well-being using a total of 123,668 answers to a survey question about “happiness.” We find that individuals have a lower tendency to report themselves happy when inequality is high, even after controlling for individual income, a large set of personal characteristics, and year and country (or, in the case of the US, state) dummies. The effect, however, is more precisely defined statistically in Europe than in the US. In addition, we find striking differences across groups. In Europe, the poor and those on the left of the political spectru
5 0.11290537 1360 andrew gelman stats-2012-06-02-Helpful on happiness
Introduction: Following on our recent discussion of contradictory findings on happiness, David Austin writes: A pellucid discussion of happiness and happiness research is Fred Feldman, What is This Thing Called Happiness? (Oxford University Press, 2010). And here’s Feldman’s summary of his book.
6 0.10999575 1105 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-08-Econ debate about prices at a fancy restaurant
7 0.10069908 1887 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-07-“Happy Money: The Science of Smarter Spending”
8 0.10028046 1835 andrew gelman stats-2013-05-02-7 ways to separate errors from statistics
10 0.09626887 437 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-29-The mystery of the U-shaped relationship between happiness and age
11 0.092642732 364 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-22-Politics is not a random walk: Momentum and mean reversion in polling
12 0.090551645 1787 andrew gelman stats-2013-04-04-Wanna be the next Tyler Cowen? It’s not as easy as you might think!
13 0.079364479 1204 andrew gelman stats-2012-03-08-The politics of economic and statistical models
14 0.079177521 1079 andrew gelman stats-2011-12-23-Surveys show Americans are populist class warriors, except when they aren’t
15 0.079087906 2255 andrew gelman stats-2014-03-19-How Americans vote
16 0.079062819 2107 andrew gelman stats-2013-11-20-NYT (non)-retraction watch
17 0.075422831 50 andrew gelman stats-2010-05-25-Looking for Sister Right
18 0.07478705 1081 andrew gelman stats-2011-12-24-Statistical ethics violation
19 0.074090235 1850 andrew gelman stats-2013-05-10-The recursion of pop-econ
20 0.073710702 711 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-14-Steven Rhoads’s book, “The Economist’s View of the World”
topicId topicWeight
[(0, 0.157), (1, -0.071), (2, 0.038), (3, -0.005), (4, -0.035), (5, -0.014), (6, 0.012), (7, 0.031), (8, 0.021), (9, 0.032), (10, -0.075), (11, -0.024), (12, -0.004), (13, 0.029), (14, 0.019), (15, 0.004), (16, -0.012), (17, 0.028), (18, 0.025), (19, -0.022), (20, 0.027), (21, -0.01), (22, -0.01), (23, -0.001), (24, -0.022), (25, 0.01), (26, 0.014), (27, -0.001), (28, -0.021), (29, 0.009), (30, -0.003), (31, 0.032), (32, -0.017), (33, -0.054), (34, -0.03), (35, -0.004), (36, 0.005), (37, 0.024), (38, -0.023), (39, -0.024), (40, 0.033), (41, -0.009), (42, 0.062), (43, 0.014), (44, -0.04), (45, 0.0), (46, 0.049), (47, -0.053), (48, 0.017), (49, 0.004)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 0.964338 1715 andrew gelman stats-2013-02-09-Thomas Hobbes would be spinning in his grave
Introduction: A few years ago I watched a bunch of Speed Racer cartoons with Phil in a movie theater in the early 90s. These were low-budget Japanese cartoons from the 60s that we loved as kids. From my adult perspective, the best parts were during the characters’ long drives, where you could see Japanese industrial scenes in the background. Similarly, sometimes the most interesting aspect of a book or article is not its overt content but rather its unexamined assumptions. I was reminded of this today when reading the Times this morning. In an interesting column reviewing recent research on happiness (marred only by his decision not to interview any psychology researchers; after all, they’re the academic experts on the topic), Adam Davidson writes : So much debate about government policy is based on economic statistics that come out of the market. But the goal of government is not just to maximize revenue. This perked me up. Not just to maximize revenue? This has to be a sign of the
Introduction: Ole Rogeberg writes: Recently read your blogpost on Pinker’s views regarding red and blue states . This might help you see where he’s coming from: The “conflict of visions” thing that Pinker repeats to likely refers to Thomas Sowell’s work in the books “Conflict of Visions” and “Visions of the anointed.” The “Conflict of visions” book is on his top-5 favorite book list and in a Q&A; interview he explains it as follows: Q: What is the Tragic Vision vs. the Utopian Vision? A: They are the different visions of human nature that underlie left-wing and right-wing ideologies. The distinction comes from the economist Thomas Sowell in his wonderful book “A Conflict of Visions.” According to the Tragic Vision, humans are inherently limited in virtue, wisdom, and knowledge, and social arrangements must acknowledge those limits. According to the Utopian vision, these limits are “products†of our social arrangements, and we should strive to overcome them in a better society of the f
3 0.78593671 711 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-14-Steven Rhoads’s book, “The Economist’s View of the World”
Introduction: About 15 years ago I ran across this book and read it, just for fun. Rhoads is a (nonquantitative) political scientist and he’s writing about basic economic concepts such as opportunity cost, marginalism, and economic incentives. As he puts it, “welfare economics is concerned with anything any individual values enough to be willing to give something up for it.” The first two-thirds of the book is all about the “economist’s view” (personally, I’d prefer to see it called the “quantitative view”) of the world and how it applies to policy issues. The quick message, which I think is more generally accepted now than in the 1970s when Rhoads started working on this book, is that free-market processes can do better than governmental rules in allocating resources. Certain ideas that are obvious to quantitative people–for example, we want to reduce pollution and reduce the incentives to pollute, but it does not make sense to try to get the level of a pollutant all the way down to zero if t
4 0.77944744 486 andrew gelman stats-2010-12-26-Age and happiness: The pattern isn’t as clear as you might think
Introduction: A couple people pointed me to this recent news article which discusses “why, beyond middle age, people get happier as they get older.” Here’s the story: When people start out on adult life, they are, on average, pretty cheerful. Things go downhill from youth to middle age until they reach a nadir commonly known as the mid-life crisis. So far, so familiar. The surprising part happens after that. Although as people move towards old age they lose things they treasure–vitality, mental sharpness and looks–they also gain what people spend their lives pursuing: happiness. This curious finding has emerged from a new branch of economics that seeks a more satisfactory measure than money of human well-being. Conventional economics uses money as a proxy for utility–the dismal way in which the discipline talks about happiness. But some economists, unconvinced that there is a direct relationship between money and well-being, have decided to go to the nub of the matter and measure happiness i
5 0.77834618 437 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-29-The mystery of the U-shaped relationship between happiness and age
Introduction: For awhile I’ve been curious (see also here ) about the U-shaped relation between happiness and age (with people least happy, on average, in their forties, and happier before and after). But when I tried to demonstrate it to me intro statistics course, using the General Social Survey, I couldn’t find the famed U, or anything like it. Using pooled GSS data mixes age, period, and cohort, so I tried throwing in some cohort effects (indicators for decades) and a couple other variables, but still couldn’t find that U. So I was intrigued when I came across this paper by Paul Frijters and Tony Beatton , who write: Whilst the majority of psychologists have concluded there is not much of a relationship at all, the economic literature has unearthed a possible U-shape relationship. In this paper we [Frijters and Beatton] replicate the U-shape for the German SocioEconomic Panel (GSOEP), and we investigate several possible explanations for it. They write: What is the relationship
6 0.77000457 98 andrew gelman stats-2010-06-19-Further thoughts on happiness and life satisfaction research
7 0.76211101 1887 andrew gelman stats-2013-06-07-“Happy Money: The Science of Smarter Spending”
8 0.75766462 2327 andrew gelman stats-2014-05-09-Nicholas Wade and the paradox of racism
9 0.75715244 1204 andrew gelman stats-2012-03-08-The politics of economic and statistical models
10 0.75561446 1633 andrew gelman stats-2012-12-21-Kahan on Pinker on politics
11 0.75117844 707 andrew gelman stats-2011-05-12-Human nature can’t be changed (except when it can)
12 0.74414527 157 andrew gelman stats-2010-07-21-Roller coasters, charity, profit, hmmm
13 0.74213713 2107 andrew gelman stats-2013-11-20-NYT (non)-retraction watch
14 0.73811209 563 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-07-Evaluating predictions of political events
15 0.73683685 630 andrew gelman stats-2011-03-27-What is an economic “conspiracy theory”?
16 0.73227739 1271 andrew gelman stats-2012-04-20-Education could use some systematic evaluation
17 0.72988641 1281 andrew gelman stats-2012-04-25-Dyson’s baffling love of crackpots
18 0.72018653 50 andrew gelman stats-2010-05-25-Looking for Sister Right
19 0.71243083 333 andrew gelman stats-2010-10-10-Psychiatric drugs and the reduction in crime
20 0.70970494 1105 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-08-Econ debate about prices at a fancy restaurant
topicId topicWeight
[(9, 0.225), (13, 0.017), (15, 0.057), (16, 0.073), (21, 0.026), (24, 0.105), (76, 0.051), (78, 0.011), (83, 0.011), (95, 0.011), (98, 0.011), (99, 0.287)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
1 0.96669948 529 andrew gelman stats-2011-01-21-“City Opens Inquiry on Grading Practices at a Top-Scoring Bronx School”
Introduction: Sharon Otterman reports : When report card grades were released in the fall for the city’s 455 high schools, the highest score went to a small school in a down-and-out section of the Bronx . . . A stunning 94 percent of its seniors graduated, more than 30 points above the citywide average. . . . “When I interviewed for the school,” said Sam Buchbinder, a history teacher, “it was made very clear: this is a school that doesn’t believe in anyone failing.” That statement was not just an exhortation to excellence. It was school policy. By order of the principal, codified in the school’s teacher handbook, all teachers should grade their classes in the same way: 30 percent of students should earn a grade in the A range, 40 percent B’s, 25 percent C’s, and no more than 5 percent D’s. As long as they show up, they should not fail. Hey, that sounds like Harvard and Columbia^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H various selective northeastern colleges I’ve known. Of course, we^H^H
2 0.96648085 1532 andrew gelman stats-2012-10-13-A real-life dollar auction game!
Introduction: Actually, $100,000 auction. I learned about it after seeing the following email which was broadcast to a couple of mailing lists: Dear all, I am now writing about something completely different! I need your help “voting” for our project, and sending this e-mail to others so that they can also vote for our project. As you will see from the video, the project would fund *** Project: I am a finalist for a $100,000 prize from Brigham and Women’s Hospital. My project is to understand how ***. Ultimately, we want to develop a ***. We expect that this ** can be used to *** Here are the instructions: 1. Go to the web page: http://brighamandwomens.org/research/BFF/default.aspx 2. scroll to the bottom and follow the link to “Vote” 3. select project #** 4. FORWARD THIS E-MAIL TO AS MANY PEOPLE AS YOU CAN. Best regards, ** I love that step 4 is in ALL CAPS, just to give it that genuine chain-letter aura. Isn’t this weird? First, that this foundation would give ou
3 0.96605998 1424 andrew gelman stats-2012-07-22-Extreme events as evidence for differences in distributions
Introduction: I think Lawrence Summers would like this paper by James Hansen, Makiko Sato, and Reto Ruedy (link from Krugman via Palko ). Hansen et al. write: The distribution of seasonal mean temperature anomalies has shifted toward higher temperatures and the range of anomalies has increased. An important change is the emergence of a category of summertime extremely hot outliers, more than three standard deviations (σ) warmer than climatology. This hot extreme, which covered much less than 1% of Earth’s surface in the period of climatology, now typically covers about 10% of the land area. The point is that it makes sense to look at the whole distribution, but extreme events provide information also. P.S. Here are some papers by my Columbia colleague Wolfram Schenkler on potential impacts of global warming on agriculture.
4 0.96419787 1356 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-31-Question 21 of my final exam for Design and Analysis of Sample Surveys
Introduction: 21. A country is divided into three regions with populations of 2 million, 2 million, and 0.5 million, respectively. A survey is done asking about foreign policy opinions.. Somebody proposes taking a sample of 50 people from each reason. Give a reason why this non-proportional sample would not usually be done, and also a reason why it might actually be a good idea. Solution to question 20 From yesterday : 20. Explain in two sentences why we expect survey respondents to be honest about vote preferences but possibly dishonest about reporting unhealty behaviors. Solution: Respondents tend to be sincere about vote preferences because this affects the outcome of the poll, and people are motivated to have their candidate poll well. This motivation is typically not present in reporting behaviors; you have no particular reason for wanting to affect the average survey response.
5 0.96396202 993 andrew gelman stats-2011-11-05-The sort of thing that gives technocratic reasoning a bad name
Introduction: 1. Freakonomics characterizes drunk driving as an example of “the human tendency to worry about rare problems that are unlikely to happen.” 2. The CDC reports , “Alcohol-impaired drivers are involved in about 1 in 3 crash deaths, resulting in nearly 11,000 deaths in 2009.” No offense to the tenured faculty at the University of Chicago, but I’m going with the CDC on this one. P.S. The Freakonomics blog deserves to be dinged another time, not just for claiming, based on implausible assumptions and making the all-else-equal fallacy that “drunk walking is 8 times more likely to result in your death than drunk driving” but for presenting this weak inference as a fact rather than as a speculation. When doing “Freakonomics,” you can be counterintuitive, or you can be sensible, but it’s hard to be both. I mean, sure, sometimes you can be. But there’s a tradeoff, and in this case, they’re choosing to push the envelope on counterintuitiveness.
6 0.96008611 577 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-16-Annals of really really stupid spam
7 0.95904183 1291 andrew gelman stats-2012-04-30-Systematic review of publication bias in studies on publication bias
8 0.95234668 1332 andrew gelman stats-2012-05-20-Problemen met het boek
9 0.94152474 1961 andrew gelman stats-2013-07-29-Postdocs in probabilistic modeling! With David Blei! And Stan!
10 0.93727541 1110 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-10-Jobs in statistics research! In New Jersey!
11 0.93662405 1226 andrew gelman stats-2012-03-22-Story time meets the all-else-equal fallacy and the fallacy of measurement
12 0.93581665 389 andrew gelman stats-2010-11-01-Why it can be rational to vote
13 0.93581486 1565 andrew gelman stats-2012-11-06-Why it can be rational to vote
same-blog 14 0.93469322 1715 andrew gelman stats-2013-02-09-Thomas Hobbes would be spinning in his grave
15 0.93229336 1664 andrew gelman stats-2013-01-10-Recently in the sister blog: Brussels sprouts, ugly graphs, and switched at birth
16 0.93184108 1142 andrew gelman stats-2012-01-29-Difficulties with the 1-4-power transformation
17 0.93074584 560 andrew gelman stats-2011-02-06-Education and Poverty
18 0.92557704 29 andrew gelman stats-2010-05-12-Probability of successive wins in baseball
19 0.91679549 1566 andrew gelman stats-2012-11-07-A question about voting systems—unrelated to U.S. elections!
20 0.91101235 640 andrew gelman stats-2011-03-31-Why Edit Wikipedia?