brendan_oconnor_ai brendan_oconnor_ai-2008 brendan_oconnor_ai-2008-130 knowledge-graph by maker-knowledge-mining
Source: html
Introduction: In 1994, the Rwandan genocide claimed 800,000 lives. This genocide was remarkable for being very low-tech — lots of non-military, average people with machetes killing their neighbors. Romeo Dallaire, the leader of the small UN peacekeeping mission there, saw it coming and was convinced he could stop much of the violence if he had 5,000 international troops plus the authority to seize weapon caches and do other aggressive intervention operations. Famously, he made a plea to his superiors and was denied . (The genocide ended only when a rebel army managed a string of military victories and forcibly stopped the killing.) Embedded video from <a href=”http://www.cnn.com/video” mce_href=”http://www.cnn.com/video”>CNN Video</a> Kofi Annan forbade him from expanding his peacekeeping mandate because there was no international support — in particular, the U.S. was not on board. A recent article from The Economist explains, And the trickiest ch
sentIndex sentText sentNum sentScore
1 This genocide was remarkable for being very low-tech — lots of non-military, average people with machetes killing their neighbors. [sent-2, score-0.654]
2 Romeo Dallaire, the leader of the small UN peacekeeping mission there, saw it coming and was convinced he could stop much of the violence if he had 5,000 international troops plus the authority to seize weapon caches and do other aggressive intervention operations. [sent-3, score-0.986]
3 (The genocide ended only when a rebel army managed a string of military victories and forcibly stopped the killing. [sent-5, score-0.76]
4 ) Embedded video from <a href=”http://www. [sent-6, score-0.089]
5 com/video”>CNN Video</a> Kofi Annan forbade him from expanding his peacekeeping mandate because there was no international support — in particular, the U. [sent-10, score-0.303]
6 A recent article from The Economist explains, And the trickiest challenge will always be the unexpected. [sent-13, score-0.066]
7 Bill Clinton is often blamed for failing to stop the killing in Rwanda. [sent-14, score-0.37]
8 He could have sent troops or at least jammed the radio broadcasts that told the killers where to go and whom to kill. [sent-15, score-0.318]
9 But he had seen a humanitarian military intervention in Somalia go bloodily awry the previous year, so he did not. [sent-16, score-0.375]
10 But, very interestingly, there seems to have been an information cost dimension to the problem: He said afterwards that he had not understood soon enough what was going on in Rwanda. [sent-17, score-0.205]
11 [Samantha Power, genocide expert and advisor to Barack Obama] retorts that he “could have known…if he had wanted to know”. [sent-18, score-0.456]
12 Even experts did not realise just how well-organised and systematic the killing was until nearly half the victims were already dead. [sent-21, score-0.282]
13 Mr Clinton could in theory have wrenched his mind away from all the other crises in the world and grasped the Rwandan situation in time to save many lives. [sent-22, score-0.368]
14 But in practice, how many presidents are that flexible? [sent-23, score-0.134]
15 As despicable and disastrous Clinton’s inaction was, I think you can’t blame him for making decisions based on the very poor amount of information they had at the time. [sent-24, score-0.275]
16 (Though the situation was definitely not as simple as the article depicts it — for example, the State Department spent months playing semantic games around the term “genocide” to avoid admitting they were standing by as one took place. [sent-25, score-0.216]
17 And there’s something to be said for a bounded rationality explanation: political leaders having very limited attentional resources for acquiring information before making decisions. [sent-29, score-0.408]
18 But compared to 1994, today we have far better infrastructure for disseminating information from the ground: mobile phones, online video, blogs/messaging/etc, and even websites specialized for gathering documentation of human rights violations like witness. [sent-30, score-0.196]
19 There might already be a test case for this hypothesis — did social media information dissemination affect the international response to Darfur? [sent-33, score-0.433]
20 Certainly many groups advocating intervention, like Save Darfur, have been tremendously helped by online organizing . [sent-34, score-0.132]
wordName wordTfidf (topN-words)
[('genocide', 0.456), ('rwandan', 0.228), ('intervention', 0.198), ('clinton', 0.198), ('killing', 0.198), ('darfur', 0.152), ('gt', 0.152), ('lt', 0.152), ('peacekeeping', 0.152), ('troops', 0.152), ('international', 0.151), ('information', 0.132), ('save', 0.121), ('http', 0.112), ('stop', 0.106), ('military', 0.106), ('could', 0.095), ('video', 0.089), ('already', 0.084), ('situation', 0.084), ('making', 0.077), ('said', 0.073), ('go', 0.071), ('many', 0.068), ('mr', 0.066), ('economist', 0.066), ('challenge', 0.066), ('leaders', 0.066), ('presidents', 0.066), ('somalia', 0.066), ('seize', 0.066), ('explains', 0.066), ('army', 0.066), ('blamed', 0.066), ('battle', 0.066), ('disastrous', 0.066), ('admitting', 0.066), ('violence', 0.066), ('dissemination', 0.066), ('depicts', 0.066), ('famously', 0.066), ('fault', 0.066), ('ignore', 0.066), ('romeo', 0.066), ('stopped', 0.066), ('string', 0.066), ('whoever', 0.066), ('online', 0.064), ('bad', 0.062), ('resources', 0.06)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 1.0000001 130 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-18-Information cost and genocide
Introduction: In 1994, the Rwandan genocide claimed 800,000 lives. This genocide was remarkable for being very low-tech — lots of non-military, average people with machetes killing their neighbors. Romeo Dallaire, the leader of the small UN peacekeeping mission there, saw it coming and was convinced he could stop much of the violence if he had 5,000 international troops plus the authority to seize weapon caches and do other aggressive intervention operations. Famously, he made a plea to his superiors and was denied . (The genocide ended only when a rebel army managed a string of military victories and forcibly stopped the killing.) Embedded video from <a href=”http://www.cnn.com/video” mce_href=”http://www.cnn.com/video”>CNN Video</a> Kofi Annan forbade him from expanding his peacekeeping mandate because there was no international support — in particular, the U.S. was not on board. A recent article from The Economist explains, And the trickiest ch
2 0.080069751 90 brendan oconnor ai-2008-01-20-Moral psychology on Amazon Mechanical Turk
Introduction: There’s a lot of exciting work in moral psychology right now. I’ve been telling various poor fools who listen to me to read something from Jonathan Haidt or Joshua Greene , but of course there’s a sea of too many articles and books of varying quality and intended audience. But just last week Steven Pinker wrote a great NYT magazine article, “The Moral Instinct,” which summarizes current research and tries to spell out a few implications. I recommend it highly, if just for presenting so many awesome examples. (Yes, this blog has poked fun at Pinker before. But in any case, he is a brilliant expository writer. The Language Instinct is still one of my favorite popular science books.) For a while now I’ve been thinking that recruiting subjects online could lend itself to collecting some really interesting behavioral science data. A few months ago I tried doing this with Amazon Mechanical Turk , a horribly misnamed web service that actually lets you create web-based tasks
3 0.077079415 109 brendan oconnor ai-2008-07-04-Link: Today’s international organizations
Introduction: Fascinating — a review of the current international system, focusing on international organizations (that is, organizations of states). Who runs the world? | Wrestling for influence | Economist.com
Introduction: I was planning to write some WordNet lookup code tonight. But instead I’ve learned of too many intersecting things. First, there are a zillion things to do this weekend ( hooray flavorpill ): Picasso and American Art exhibit continuing at SFMOMA . I saw it very briefly last weekend but want some more. And Doug claims there’s an interesting photography exhibit there too. Reading from We Don’t Need Another Wave: Dispatches from the Next Generation of Feminists , a fascinating looking book I’ve seen many times in the bookstores around here. By that I mean at least Modern Times (the neat Mission bookstore) and the Anarchist Collective Bookstore (out on the Haight). And the reading is at Modern Times, just down the street from my house! Amazing. Tomorrow at 7:30. Since anarchists were just mentioned, fortuitously there also appears: the Bay Area Anarchist Bookfair this Saturday and Sunday! Speakers and books down by Golden Gate Park, oh my. Can’t say I’m a ra
5 0.073131107 129 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-03-Statistics vs. Machine Learning, fight!
Introduction: 10/1/09 update — well, it’s been nearly a year, and I should say not everything in this rant is totally true, and I certainly believe much less of it now. Current take: Statistics , not machine learning, is the real deal, but unfortunately suffers from bad marketing. On the other hand, to the extent that bad marketing includes misguided undergraduate curriculums, there’s plenty of room to improve for everyone. So it’s pretty clear by now that statistics and machine learning aren’t very different fields. I was recently pointed to a very amusing comparison by the excellent statistician — and machine learning expert — Robert Tibshiriani . Reproduced here: Glossary Machine learning Statistics network, graphs model weights parameters learning fitting generalization test set performance supervised learning regression/classification unsupervised learning density estimation, clustering large grant = $1,000,000
6 0.069592036 28 brendan oconnor ai-2005-11-20-science writing bad!
7 0.067598939 99 brendan oconnor ai-2008-04-02-Datawocky: More data usually beats better algorithms
8 0.067118824 7 brendan oconnor ai-2005-06-25-looking for related blogs-links
9 0.063242197 83 brendan oconnor ai-2007-11-15-Actually that 2008 elections voter fMRI study is batshit insane (and sleazy too)
10 0.062357776 56 brendan oconnor ai-2007-04-05-Evil
11 0.061199959 46 brendan oconnor ai-2007-01-02-Anarchy vs. social order in Somalia
12 0.056346886 131 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-27-Facebook sentiment mining predicts presidential polls
13 0.050454207 144 brendan oconnor ai-2009-06-14-Psychometrics quote
14 0.050339282 86 brendan oconnor ai-2007-12-20-Data-driven charity
15 0.049935754 65 brendan oconnor ai-2007-06-17-"Time will tell, epistemology won’t"
16 0.049808804 2 brendan oconnor ai-2004-11-24-addiction & 2 problems of economics
17 0.048631441 61 brendan oconnor ai-2007-05-24-Rock Paper Scissors psychology
18 0.047959741 188 brendan oconnor ai-2012-10-02-Powerset’s natural language search system
19 0.047810949 38 brendan oconnor ai-2006-06-03-Neuroeconomics reviews
20 0.047622953 179 brendan oconnor ai-2012-02-02-Histograms — matplotlib vs. R
topicId topicWeight
[(0, -0.194), (1, 0.048), (2, -0.029), (3, -0.078), (4, -0.051), (5, -0.019), (6, -0.024), (7, -0.009), (8, 0.01), (9, -0.026), (10, -0.002), (11, 0.047), (12, -0.022), (13, -0.023), (14, -0.003), (15, -0.003), (16, -0.021), (17, -0.041), (18, 0.03), (19, 0.056), (20, -0.081), (21, -0.018), (22, 0.066), (23, 0.004), (24, -0.028), (25, -0.043), (26, -0.016), (27, -0.018), (28, -0.051), (29, 0.116), (30, 0.081), (31, 0.04), (32, -0.021), (33, -0.054), (34, -0.181), (35, 0.096), (36, -0.002), (37, 0.009), (38, -0.034), (39, 0.073), (40, 0.02), (41, 0.038), (42, 0.033), (43, 0.159), (44, -0.103), (45, -0.038), (46, 0.019), (47, 0.077), (48, 0.094), (49, 0.015)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
same-blog 1 0.97894907 130 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-18-Information cost and genocide
Introduction: In 1994, the Rwandan genocide claimed 800,000 lives. This genocide was remarkable for being very low-tech — lots of non-military, average people with machetes killing their neighbors. Romeo Dallaire, the leader of the small UN peacekeeping mission there, saw it coming and was convinced he could stop much of the violence if he had 5,000 international troops plus the authority to seize weapon caches and do other aggressive intervention operations. Famously, he made a plea to his superiors and was denied . (The genocide ended only when a rebel army managed a string of military victories and forcibly stopped the killing.) Embedded video from <a href=”http://www.cnn.com/video” mce_href=”http://www.cnn.com/video”>CNN Video</a> Kofi Annan forbade him from expanding his peacekeeping mandate because there was no international support — in particular, the U.S. was not on board. A recent article from The Economist explains, And the trickiest ch
2 0.53801394 90 brendan oconnor ai-2008-01-20-Moral psychology on Amazon Mechanical Turk
Introduction: There’s a lot of exciting work in moral psychology right now. I’ve been telling various poor fools who listen to me to read something from Jonathan Haidt or Joshua Greene , but of course there’s a sea of too many articles and books of varying quality and intended audience. But just last week Steven Pinker wrote a great NYT magazine article, “The Moral Instinct,” which summarizes current research and tries to spell out a few implications. I recommend it highly, if just for presenting so many awesome examples. (Yes, this blog has poked fun at Pinker before. But in any case, he is a brilliant expository writer. The Language Instinct is still one of my favorite popular science books.) For a while now I’ve been thinking that recruiting subjects online could lend itself to collecting some really interesting behavioral science data. A few months ago I tried doing this with Amazon Mechanical Turk , a horribly misnamed web service that actually lets you create web-based tasks
3 0.53721547 87 brendan oconnor ai-2007-12-26-What is experimental philosophy?
Introduction: Experimental philosophy: Suppose the chairman of a company has to decide whether to adopt a new program. It would increase profits and help the environment too. “I don’t care at all about helping the environment,” the chairman says. “I just want to make as much profit as I can. Let’s start the new program.” Would you say that the chairman intended to help the environment? O.K., same circumstance. Except this time the program would harm the environment. The chairman, who still couldn’t care less about the environment, authorizes the program in order to get those profits. As expected, the bottom line goes up, the environment goes down. Would you say the chairman harmed the environment intentionally? in one survey, only 23 percent of people said that the chairman in the first situation had intentionally helped the environment. When they had to think about the second situation, though, fully 82 percent thought that the chairman had intentionally harmed the environment. There’s plen
4 0.49300721 109 brendan oconnor ai-2008-07-04-Link: Today’s international organizations
Introduction: Fascinating — a review of the current international system, focusing on international organizations (that is, organizations of states). Who runs the world? | Wrestling for influence | Economist.com
5 0.44762781 56 brendan oconnor ai-2007-04-05-Evil
Introduction: I must be too cynical. I thought I didn’t like Philip Zimbardo ‘s theatrics, but regardless I really appreciated this NYT interview with him on the universal capacity for evil. (S.P.E. is the Stanford Prison Experiment , whose pictures here are from that lovely basement hallway, still there behind the 420-40 and 41 lecture rooms.) In particular: Q. What was your reaction when you first saw those photographs from Abu Ghraib? A. I was shocked. But not surprised. I immediately flashed on similar pictures from the S.P.E. What particularly bothered me was that the Pentagon blamed the whole thing on a “few bad apples.” I knew from our experiment, if you put good apples into a bad situation, you’ll get bad apples. That was why I was willing to be an expert witness for Sgt. Chip Frederick, who was ultimately sentenced to eight years for his role at Abu Ghraib. Frederick was the Army reservist who was put in charge of the night shift at Tier 1A, where detainees were abused. Fr
6 0.41897169 99 brendan oconnor ai-2008-04-02-Datawocky: More data usually beats better algorithms
7 0.41399297 153 brendan oconnor ai-2009-09-08-Patches to Rainbow, the old text classifier that won’t go away
8 0.41074276 19 brendan oconnor ai-2005-07-09-the psychology of design as explanation
9 0.40493509 125 brendan oconnor ai-2008-11-21-Netflix Prize
10 0.39018747 3 brendan oconnor ai-2004-12-02-go science
11 0.38668284 131 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-27-Facebook sentiment mining predicts presidential polls
12 0.38340208 27 brendan oconnor ai-2005-09-07-Kurzweil interview
13 0.3790068 46 brendan oconnor ai-2007-01-02-Anarchy vs. social order in Somalia
14 0.37711108 122 brendan oconnor ai-2008-11-05-Obama street celebrations in San Francisco
15 0.37211037 111 brendan oconnor ai-2008-08-16-A better Obama vs McCain poll aggregation
16 0.36231905 184 brendan oconnor ai-2012-07-04-The $60,000 cat: deep belief networks make less sense for language than vision
17 0.35978532 35 brendan oconnor ai-2006-04-28-Easterly vs. Sachs on global poverty
18 0.35081029 78 brendan oconnor ai-2007-09-26-EEG for the Wii and in your basement
19 0.34866622 154 brendan oconnor ai-2009-09-10-Don’t MAWK AWK – the fastest and most elegant big data munging language!
20 0.34612504 178 brendan oconnor ai-2011-11-13-Bayes update view of pointwise mutual information
topicId topicWeight
[(16, 0.041), (39, 0.01), (43, 0.016), (44, 0.083), (45, 0.44), (48, 0.02), (55, 0.036), (70, 0.035), (72, 0.019), (74, 0.17), (80, 0.029)]
simIndex simValue blogId blogTitle
1 0.9024421 143 brendan oconnor ai-2009-06-04-June 4
Introduction: BBC News – June 4, 1989, Tiananmen Square Massacre Also worth reading: Nicholas Kristof’s riveting firsthand account .
same-blog 2 0.87173796 130 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-18-Information cost and genocide
Introduction: In 1994, the Rwandan genocide claimed 800,000 lives. This genocide was remarkable for being very low-tech — lots of non-military, average people with machetes killing their neighbors. Romeo Dallaire, the leader of the small UN peacekeeping mission there, saw it coming and was convinced he could stop much of the violence if he had 5,000 international troops plus the authority to seize weapon caches and do other aggressive intervention operations. Famously, he made a plea to his superiors and was denied . (The genocide ended only when a rebel army managed a string of military victories and forcibly stopped the killing.) Embedded video from <a href=”http://www.cnn.com/video” mce_href=”http://www.cnn.com/video”>CNN Video</a> Kofi Annan forbade him from expanding his peacekeeping mandate because there was no international support — in particular, the U.S. was not on board. A recent article from The Economist explains, And the trickiest ch
3 0.38907975 203 brendan oconnor ai-2014-02-19-What the ACL-2014 review scores mean
Introduction: I’ve had several people ask me what the numbers in ACL reviews mean — and I can’t find anywhere online where they’re described. (Can anyone point this out if it is somewhere?) So here’s the review form, below. They all go from 1 to 5, with 5 the best. I think the review emails to authors only include a subset of the below — for example, “Overall Recommendation” is not included? The CFP said that they have different types of review forms for different types of papers. I think this one is for a standard full paper. I guess what people really want to know is what scores tend to correspond to acceptances. I really have no idea and I get the impression this can change year to year. I have no involvement with the ACL conference besides being one of many, many reviewers. APPROPRIATENESS (1-5) Does the paper fit in ACL 2014? (Please answer this question in light of the desire to broaden the scope of the research areas represented at ACL.) 5: Certainly. 4: Probabl
4 0.38413817 123 brendan oconnor ai-2008-11-12-Disease tracking with web queries and social messaging (Google, Twitter, Facebook…)
Introduction: This is a good idea: in a search engine’s query logs, look for outbreaks of queries like [[flu symptoms]] in a given region. I’ve heard (from Roddy ) that this trick also works well on Facebook statuses (e.g. “Feeling crappy this morning, think I just got the flu”). Google Uses Web Searches to Track Flu’s Spread – NYTimes.com Google Flu Trends – google.org For an example with a publicly available data feed, these queries works decently well on Twitter search: [[ flu -shot -google ]] (high recall) [[ "muscle aches" flu -shot ]] (high precision) The “muscle aches” query is too sparse and the general query is too noisy, but you could imagine some more tricks to clean it up, then train a classifier, etc. With a bit more work it looks like geolocation information can be had out of the Twitter search API .
5 0.37545288 26 brendan oconnor ai-2005-09-02-cognitive modelling is rational choice++
Introduction: Rational choice has been a huge imperialistic success, growing in popularity and being applied to more and more fields. Why is this? It’s not because the rational choice model of decision-making is particularly realistic. Rather, it’s because rational choice is a completely specified theory of human behavior , and therefore is great at generating hypotheses. Given any situation involving people, rational choice can be used to generate a hypothesis about what to expect. That is, you just ask, “What would a person do to maximize their own benefit?” Similar things have been said about evolutionary psychology: you can always predict behavior by asking “what would hunter-gatherers do?” Now, certainly both rational choice and evolutionary psychology don’t always generate correct hypotheses, but they’re incredibly useful because they at least give you a starting point. Witness the theory of bounded rationality: just like rational choice, except amended to consider computational l
6 0.37414739 129 brendan oconnor ai-2008-12-03-Statistics vs. Machine Learning, fight!
7 0.37366471 63 brendan oconnor ai-2007-06-10-Freak-Freakonomics (Ariel Rubinstein is the shit!)
8 0.36888945 105 brendan oconnor ai-2008-06-05-Clinton-Obama support visualization
9 0.36683652 77 brendan oconnor ai-2007-09-15-Dollar auction
10 0.36426604 19 brendan oconnor ai-2005-07-09-the psychology of design as explanation
11 0.35623905 188 brendan oconnor ai-2012-10-02-Powerset’s natural language search system
12 0.35561585 86 brendan oconnor ai-2007-12-20-Data-driven charity
13 0.3537637 138 brendan oconnor ai-2009-04-17-1 billion web page dataset from CMU
14 0.35024458 152 brendan oconnor ai-2009-09-08-Another R flashmob today
17 0.33395356 2 brendan oconnor ai-2004-11-24-addiction & 2 problems of economics
18 0.33106425 184 brendan oconnor ai-2012-07-04-The $60,000 cat: deep belief networks make less sense for language than vision
19 0.33053407 200 brendan oconnor ai-2013-09-13-Response on our movie personas paper
20 0.32649419 80 brendan oconnor ai-2007-10-31-neo institutional economic fun!